u/Select-Nectarine8795

Decolonising Our Minds Should Be Our First Priority

One of the biggest obstacles to India’s progress is not something imposed on us from outside anymore. It is the way many of us have learned to see ourselves.

The vast majority of Indians I speak to seem to carry an unspoken assumption that anything Indian is automatically inferior to its foreign counterpart. Foreign is sophisticated; Indian is backward. Imported is premium; local is cheap. English is aspirational; our native languages are somehow lesser. And travelling abroad is treated as an achievement in itself, while exploring our own country is often seen as something secondary.

Take tourism. For many Indians, the passport stamp seems to be the point of the holiday. A foreign destination automatically carries more prestige than a domestic one, even when the experience of travelling within India can be far more culturally transformative. For someone from Kochi, travelling to Sri Lanka may involve less cultural shock than travelling to Rajasthan, yet the former is often considered the more impressive trip simply because it is international.

The same mindset is even more visible in language.

Speaking English is often treated as a marker of intelligence, education and status, while speaking our native languages can be perceived as unsophisticated. People are actively discouraged from using their own languages in professional and academic spaces. Some of the highest levels of academia and public discourse in India still operate almost entirely in English, even when the people participating in them are based in communities with rich native languages of their own. What makes this particularly striking is that languages elsewhere in the world have not been forced into the same dependence. European languages with populations of only a few million speakers routinely develop their own vocabulary for science, technology and other specialised fields. Yet many Indian languages are expected to borrow English terminology whenever a concept becomes more complicated than a 5-year-old's everyday conversation.

We have reached a point where even saying dhanyavada instead of “thank you” can make someone uncomfortable because they worry that the other person might be offended by the assumption that they don't speak English. But when did English become our priority over our own languages?

Even our infamous language wars often miss this larger picture. Arguments over Hindi versus regional languages are legitimate, but English remains the far greater threat to the vitality of all Indian languages. It is entirely possible to spend an entire day in an Indian city without using the language spoken by the people around you.

Look at my own generation, Gen Z. Many young Indians either speak almost exclusively in English or speak what they call an “Indian language” that is often 90% English vocabulary with a few native-language connectors. There is nothing inherently wrong with speaking English when necessary. The problem is when English becomes the default measure of intelligence, sophistication and social status, while our own languages become something to be embarrassed about.

The same hierarchy exists in what we consume.

Imported food and products are routinely assumed to be better simply because they are imported. There are countless examples like this, but we often fail to appreciate them because we have already decided that foreign equals superior.

And this mindset extends even to people.

Foreigners are frequently perceived as more attractive, more capable and more sophisticated. Indians can internalise the idea that being foreign automatically makes someone desirable, while being Indian makes someone ordinary or even undesirable. We see this in everything from beauty standards to professional competence.

Even in sports and physical activities, the explanation is sometimes reduced to genetics. I climb and I surf, and whenever I do these things in India, I have repeatedly encountered some version of the same reaction: Why are you doing this? Beneath the question is often the assumption that these are things foreigners do. Somehow, an Indian person participating in them is unusual simply because they are Indian.

That is the absurdity of the mindset we have inherited.

We have been taught, consciously or unconsciously, to associate foreignness with excellence and Indianness with inadequacy. Going abroad is treated as the ultimate achievement. Behaving like a foreigner is considered cool. Acting as though you don't belong to this country can be a status symbol. Anything Indian can be dismissed as “cringe” while anything foreign is automatically considered sophisticated.

And this mindset has survived for generations, even though the invaders that shaped so much of it had the last of them kicked out nearly a century ago.

That is why decolonising our minds should be our first priority.

This does not mean rejecting everything foreign, nor does it mean pretending that everything Indian is inherently good. There is plenty we can learn from the rest of the world, and there is nothing wrong with speaking English in an international context, travelling abroad, eating imported food or appreciating foreign cultures.

The problem is the assumption that foreign is better by default.

We need to be able to look at something Indian and evaluate it on its own merits. We should be able to criticise what deserves criticism and celebrate what deserves celebration without automatically assigning higher value to something simply because it came from somewhere else.

Because ultimately, the world will see us only as highly as we see ourselves.

If we constantly tell ourselves that our languages are inferior, our products are inferior, our culture is inferior, our people are inferior and our country is inferior, it should not surprise us when that perception eventually becomes a widely held belief outside India too.

Decolonisation is therefore not about hating the West. It is about removing the hierarchy in our own heads.

We don't need to become less open to the world to stop believing that being Indian makes us less than the world.

reddit.com
u/Select-Nectarine8795 — 9 days ago

Hot Take: We don't need western tourists

I’m almost relieved that India has lost its shine among western “traveller” circles (iykyk). Too many of them don't realise that they only arrive here as guests yet behave as though they are entitled to our landscapes, our culture, and our hospitality. Conversations with them often spiral into obscure criticisms of India that reek of racism and contempt. Of course we face issues with pollution and population. But these challenges are ours to solve, and they are hardly unique to India. Nepal and Sri Lanka face very similar issues, yet western tourists flock there without complaint. Ironically, they choose to visit India’s most polluted hubs, like the Golden Triangle, which have indeed become exploitative toward tourists as it happens to literally every major tourist destination (eg: Venice), but then use that as a blanket indictment of the entire country.

Worse still, they project their imagined fascist, racist, oppressive caricature of India’s government onto all Indians. They are hell-bent on seeing us as a 1.4 billion strong monolith rather than individuals. Our government is far from perfect, but it is nowhere near the dystopia painted by western journalism, which seems intent on vilifying India and its people. And when these tourists do come, they retreat into “white-only” enclaves in Rishikesh, Dharamshala, Hampi, Gokarna, and Varkala, much like the Israeli communities in the Himalayas or Andamans. Goa was once the prime example, though it become too mainstream for them recently. I fear that the Northeast is next on the menu.

The problem isn’t only external; our own tourist infrastructure often discriminates against Indians. I remember going to surf in Goa a few years ago, only to be denied a surfboard rental because the surf school owner assumed I couldn’t swim or handle the mild conditions. Minutes later, a white couple casually returned their rented boards to the same shop. Unfortunately, these tourist hubs are plagued with coconuts.

The same ignorance unfortunately surfaces in my other hobbies too. In a post on r/ mountaineering (that reddit doesn't let me attach), a woman ranted about not being allowed to bring her satellite communications device into India. A little research would have told her it’s banned here for good reason Our strict border security stems from a history of terrorist threats. It frustrates me too when traveling, but I understand the intent. Yet the comments under her post turned this into another excuse to degrade India, its people, and its government. The only sensible nuanced comment on this post is the most downvoted - make of that what you will.

I believe that if you know where to go, India is objectively the best country to travel in the region. Its sheer size and diversity mean it offers everything neighboring countries do, and often more, at similar or greater quality. I only hope that those who come here with racist contempt never get to experience it.

(I used AI to rephrase some paragraphs)

reddit.com
u/Select-Nectarine8795 — 11 days ago