Store-bought was draining my wallet, so I made my own toner
I started making my own toner about six months ago, mostly because I was spending way too much on storebought products and wanted to know exactly what was going on my skin. After a lot of trial and error I landed on something simple: witch hazel as a base with a few drops of rose water and a tiny bit of vegetable glycerin for hydration. My skin honestly feels more balanced than it ever did with anything I bought off the shelf.
The ratio I settled on is roughly three parts witch hazel to one part rose water with just a few drops of glycerin per small bottle. I keep it refrigerated, which also helps with puffiness in the morning.
What I'm still figuring out is whether adding something like green tea or aloe vera juice would actually improve it or just complicate things. I've read mixed opinions on both and I don't want to mess with something that's currently working.
I know a lot of people here have way more experience than me so I'm genuinely curious what combinations others have landed on. Did you find certain ingredients caused irritation even when individually they seemed fine together? Also curious if anyone has played around with preservatives for longer shelf life, since I'm currently making very small batches to avoid waste.
Would love to hear what your goto formulas look like.