Season 4: Gimmicks and Remake famous movies
The concept of TV show episodes remaking famous episodes is not new. What is new with SNW Season 4 is that it looks like it is an assumed strategy by the writers.
>the showrunners designed each episode as a unique mini-movie that homages classic cinematic genres and older stories rather than doing literal "remakes"
They can justify it by claiming not making literal remakes but so far it has been remakes with the most memorable scenes literally redone.
Let's look at past famous movies and remake them in an episode. In previous season it was ennemy mine. Season 4 it is 65 millions with Adam Driver, The Hangover, Event Horizon and this week Casablanca.
Recycling past themes and past stories is one thing but stealing "render hommage" in season 4 is so noticeable that it become distracting.
Worse, they steal from famous movies. The "if you steal, you better off stealing from the best" does not work in movies. Everybody knows the movie and the new version is immediately compared to the original and I am sorry until now does not come out on top.
It is incredibly difficult to improve on what many perceive as some of the best movies/scenes. They would be better off stealing from an obscure movies or mediocre movie and then improve on it. Quentin Tarentino made a career out of it. His initial movies were just rip off of Asian and specifically Hong Kong movies that had never been released in the US except as cheap direct to video.
Copying the storyline of Casablanca is fine. Many movies have done it. Some more successfully than others. However copying the song scene was ridiculous as it never convey the same poignancy than in Casablanca where the French Hymn is drowning the German song.
Also in order to make it even more obvious they use black and white. The problem is that lighting for black and white require the kind of expertise that was unfortunately severely lacking.
Even with strong colour grading good black and white requires adapting the lighting on set. It must be changed to harsh sharp light. Contrast and highlight have to be exagerated. But that often results in awful normal colour. It is obvious that they did not dare to fully commit when filming in case they changed their mind in post and had to reshoot the entire episode. That resulted in an episode where you could barely see what was going on. Worse many of actors were black making any sudden juxtaposition with white actors even more obvious the lack of lighting skills.