u/Super-Shenron

I mean sure, he kinda let slide Badger wiping a town off the map, but that aside, surely you can understand his point of view? He couldn't possibly welcome another killer, after all. He's a thief too. Stealing gas is wrong, even if he didn't know it belonged to the New Frontier. He even made friends with another thief, Clementine. Why'd she come back anyway? David banished her a long time ago, and it's not like they stole her baby or anything.

Max and Joan admitted she did the raids, but they sounded too sympathetic to be evil. On the other hand, Joan brought legit points about David trying to break apart the New Frontier. A little raids there and there is a fair price to pay to keep them all together. Still, Clint was right: murder in Richmond is wrong. Sure, he was a lil slow to speak against David's execution. Or prevent Ava, one of his people, from dying, but you can't deny the sentiment is noble. He saved Javi and the others. They might have still died from some walkers, but at least they had a fighting chance. David refusing the deal and even killing Clint over a grudge was 100% irrational and counter-productive. Getting hung up on the noose is no reason to act like this. At all.

Clint made mistakes, but I am convinced he was a good man.

Remember, it's not necessarily THE worst experience, just the one that failed to live up to your expectations the most.

Given the determinant nature of some relationships, you may answer based on your own playthrough.