Note: Only brawlers with at least three games played were taken into consideration.
Finx also has a 15.9% play rate, kinda forgot to put it on there...
Feel free to let me know if I made any mistakes, I made it while watching the stream so there might be some errors.
Anyway's Colette is absolutely disgusting....
Top 3 most globally banned brawlers compared, the badges are for that too
Colette might genuinely be the strongest brawler in the game right now. I was originally just replying to another comment when I looked at the data more closely and realized how absurd her numbers actually are.
She gets played every single time she’s left open, and wins...? I feel like no one is really talking about how absurd she really is, except the pro's who are actively afraid to let her through draft.
Based on this data, I’m pretty confident Colette is the strongest brawler in the game right now.
HOWEVER, this is starting to line up with what I mentioned in my Previous Tier List using scrim data, where Sirius already had a noticeably lower win rate and I suggested he might have been a bit overrated even before any changes.
So yes I understand we’re dealing with a VERY small data set I do have the question of: Is Sirius genuinely overrated now, or is it just a "bad performance" of the pro's.
Curious about what others think?
------Info------
The tier list is simply my interpretation of the data, feel free to draw your own conclusion.
All data shown on the last two slides are data purely from scrips, total scrim dataset: 1030 Sets.
Damian: while he hasn't been playable in scrims yet I think there's no way he falls outside of the S-tier.
Jessie: Jessie is the only brawler that hasn't received a single game played, there wasn't even one single scenario where the pro's thought Jessie was a good option. Yet it's a control based meta, if Jessie can't even shine in this meta I think she's possibly even worse than F.
------Less S Tiers?------
I know it might look weird that I don’t have many S-tier brawlers, but there’s a reason for that. They are ranked based on how dominant they are in the current meta, not just how strong they are overall.
So S-tier means a brawler really stands out right now. Even if newer brawlers are stronger because of power creep, that doesn’t automatically make them S-tier.
For example, today’s A-tier could probably beat A-tier from a few months ago, but that doesn’t mean they should all be S. The tiers are about how they compare to each other right now.
In other words: S-tiers in this meta are just as dominant as S-tiers in previous metas using this method. So having fewer S-tiers this month means the meta is less defined by a few brawlers and more spread out (the meta is more balanced, even if it doesn't feel like that because the average brawler got stronger--Power Creep).
------Outliners------
Larry & Lawrie: The twin's have 'finally' become completely unplayable in the pro scene since their release in 2023.
Bea: I find it quite funny that Bea just got completely replaced by Pierce who just does Bea's role.. but better.
Squeak: Genuinely what the hell happened, I know previous metas were to fast for him but this more 'control' based meta should be favoring him. What's going on?
Bibi: The fact that Bibi is already barely C-tier yet remains dominant in lower ranks is looking rough for her future in the competitive scene.
Bo: Honestly still no idea why Bo fell down this much (A -> C, with no nerfs) if anyone could explain what is going on here please enlighten me.
Ziggy: I think Ziggy might be semi-underrated right now, this meta doesn't favor him but I'm expecting him to rise back to the B-Tier once the meta is more balanced towards him. He's still by far still the strongest "thrower" in the game. (Obviously not counting Willow and Sirius)
Clancy: Clancy's nerf made him actually semi-balanced??? Did the devs finally cook with those balance changes?
Lola: Even while bugged she cannot manage to crack into the B-tier...
Shade: Shade fell off slightly because Griff wallbreak, but once that gets a nerf I'm assuming he'll rise back to A again.
Najia & Sirius: Welcome to the two most OVERRATED brawlers in brawl stars right now. While both of them can be really toxic and annoying to face they are actually not THAT broken anymore. Not to mention that this meta doesn't really favour them, one Edgar on their face and they're cooked.
Lumi: I totally expected her to be S, but I guess the Edgar + Mortis are keeping her in check, if Lumi stays like this and either one of them gets nerfed it's highly likely that she'll rise to the S.
Stu: Yeah so I knew that he was being underrated by nearly everyone, because he counters so many brawlers at the top of the meta. But that he was top 10 level strong is kinda shocking...