One of the dumbest claims I see thrown around from the mouth of every flavor of Star Wars fans is about Lucas's talent because they forget that Lucas didn't do anything related to actual filmmaking for nearly two decades before the prequels.
No joke, the Prequels are the worst because Lucas didn't do anything for those 20 years.
Look, I get that the Prequels are bad. They are. It's fucking legendary that they're bad in all the ways you summarize them. In my opinion, Rise of Skywalker has more watchability than Revenge of the Sith mainly because Hayden is Hayden, and Daisy is an actor.
But every single goddamn time I see people slander Lucas's work on A New Hope, Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi, I lose my shit so fucking hard.
His ex-wife Marcia Lucas literally said it was his imagination despite being involved with making it work. George Lucas wasn't just a film nerd who had respect from the big shots, he made things like American Graffiti and THX 1138 alongside her, and these films are...
...I never actually want to watch either of it because Ahsoka's design during his time. And Maron. But he helped make Indiana Jones! Yes he can a horn-dog and not that great in dialogue before, but he was capable of making Star Wars because he had it. And gathering and listening is also a part of his instincts.
But my point is that this is disturbingly obvious that Lucas lost a lot of that skill during the 20 years he did nothing related to the craft of films. He didn't do any film editing, didn't try to bounce onto shows until Clone Wars which was after the Prequels.
Like, imagine something as intensive as directing, and deciding to not work on that skill despite being a film nerd for 2 whole decades.