DMT: Even if God appeared tomorrow with proof, that still wouldn't make him worthy of worship.
A friend brought up the usual hypothetical a few weeks ago: what would you do if God appeared tomorrow and somehow made it impossible to doubt that he was actually God?
Most people at the table said they'd kneel. I said I'd probably have a lot of questions first.
Because proving that you're God only proves that you're God. It doesn't automatically prove that you're good, or that I owe you worship.
And if we're talking about the God described in the Bible, there are some pretty serious questions there. The flood. Job. The destruction of entire groups of people. Hell, depending on how you understand it. I'm supposed to look at all of that and conclude that unlimited power must also mean unlimited moral authority?
The usual answer is that God's ways are beyond human understanding. But that creates a weird problem. If being more powerful means you're automatically beyond moral judgment, then morality has basically become another word for whoever has the most power.
I don't have a problem with people finding meaning or comfort in religion. I'm questioning the assumption that worship is automatically the right response to power.
If God is good, I'd want to know why. If the answer is simply "because he's God," then that's not really an answer.