u/Treywolf93

Image 1 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 2 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 3 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 4 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 5 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 6 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 7 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question
Image 8 — TCGPlayer Card Condition Question

TCGPlayer Card Condition Question

Hello all,

I have been buying some NM cards on TCG Player recently. It’s the first time I’ve ever bought from there. In my opinion, I’ve had a mixed experience on the condition of the cards received. I am pretty annoyed with a couple of the cards and am considering asking for either a return or partial refund, but also want to make sure I am being reasonable so hoping for some feedback!

I’ve ordered and received 10 cards. 7 of them were basically pristine with good or better centering. 3 of them were not. The first one was clearly LP (or maybe even worse) so I got a 10% refund without incident. The other two are below. What would you do with these if they were listed at NM? Of note, these are both SP’s, so I’m especially irritated lol. Maybe my standards are too high though. Also, each have similar issues. Just one corner has whitening on the back of each. The Mihawk is definitely the worst of the two, but the Nami is the most expensive card I’ve bought so it stinks. Including the face of the cards are just to show what they are!

Thanks in advance.

P.S. if this isn’t the right place for this post please let me know and sorry if so.

u/Treywolf93 — 21 hours ago