roast my calm ai-news app. 800 users tried it, most never came back
built this solo out of bangalore. it's kapyn (https://www.kapyn.app/), ai/tech news as swipeable 30-second cards. inshorts, but only for ai. no paywall, no hype, no 20 open tabs.
the pitch i tell myself: everyone else does ai news loud and firehose-y (x, tldr, every newsletter). i went the opposite way, calm and distilled, one thing at a time. and there's a second half most people never see: "radar", a directory of new ai tools / mcp servers / claude skills. basically "what's actually worth trying this week" instead of just "what happened".
here's the part i actually want roasted:
- ~800 users, all organic, and retention is bad. people try it once, swipe through, and don't come back. i genuinely can't tell if that's an onboarding problem, a "news is a commodity" problem, or a "nobody wants this" problem.
- i keep telling myself the calm angle plus radar is the moat. said out loud it sounds like cope. is "calm ai news" a real wedge or am i just describing a worse version of stuff that already exists for free.
- the landing page and the first 30 seconds in the app, no idea if they land or if i've just been staring at it too long to see it.
so rip it apart. positioning, retention, the name, the landing page, whether radar is the actual product and the news is a distraction, all of it. i'd rather hear the brutal version now than keep polishing something nobody returns to.
what's the first thing that made you go "nope", the concept itself or something in the first ten seconds?