
Vibes, Toxic Fanboys and Kindness
Salutations!
As the enshitification of Reddit continues and AI/bots flood most subs, we're proud to be one of the few bastions of human interaction. I love knowing it's a human on the other end who just discovered that Elden Ring is not for them or that Huniepop is much better than a porn game has any right to be.
That being said we'd like to address a few concerns that have cropped up:
"I ain't reading all that"
This is a discussion sub. If you don't enjoy reading some nerds 50 paragraph essay about how much they love Mega Man Battle Network then please move on.
It's okay to ask someone to add paragraphs to a wall of text or lightly tease about bad grammar or typo, but any comment about how people write too much will result in you being shown the door.
"This sub just dumps on popular games"
Our regulars know this isn't true, but I wanted to understand the mindset.
Quick note: One of our moderation policies is if you're going to bitch about a game being bad, you have to be able to articulate why you didn't enjoy it. Usually we nuke unstructured rants, but you folks are really good at downvoting the ones we don't catch into oblivion. Thanks for that.
I looked at the past few years worth of reviews as well as the top 100 from the last year. I also spot checked some of the more popular games on here (IE: Elden Ring, Disco Elysium, Subnautica etc...), about ~80ish reviews in all there. I ignored multi-reviews.
Here's a simple break down:
| Vibe | Last 300 | Top 100 | Popular |
|---|---|---|---|
| Positive | 76% | 62% | 53% |
| Mixed | 13% | 20% | 25% |
| Negative | 11% | 18% | 22% |
Negative reviews tend to be in the significant minority so if you think this sub is only negative, maybe stop clicking on only negative reviews?
https://i.imgur.com/Zq0iBJK.jpg
Some thoughts:
Popular games tend to attract a wider audience so there's more likely to be a "I just didn't get it..." thread from someone who was told it was going to be an amazing game. This Outer Wilds thread from 2 months ago perfectly explains this. We don't recommend Druidstone to everyone with a pulse so you see far less reviews about it.
Some people who wrote negative reviews and got downvoted may have deleted their posts, skewing the numbers a bit. However, it wouldn't be enough to flip the majority here.
Some positive reviews had "This sub hates games lol!" comments which says to me some people go out of their way to focus on the negative.
If you rely on your Reddit feed, you're slightly more likely to see negative posts since they tend to get more activity. The Reddit algorithm loves controversy.
"How dare you! I read Stellar Blade for the articles."
One of the points of this sub is you can not only talk about games free from the hype of release, but also free from the rabid defense by subreddit superfans. Here you can talk about your mixed feelings on Baldur's Gate 3 without having to worry that people with Astarion body pillows might take it personally.
I should know. I have a Solmyr body pillow and I just cry into it when people talk trash about Heroes of Might and Magic 3.
We've had a several run ins with people who get -very- upset when you poke fun at their favorite game. We ask that if someone starts going off rails that you don't absolutely love every aspect of a game they've made their entire personality, please just report them. Do not engage.
"Git gud"
We've seen a spike in this meme response.
A lot of people are going to play games outside of their comfort zone. "Git gud" or "Skill issue" with no other context/follow up will get removed and repeat offenders (or people commenting that on 4 year old posts what the fuck) will be shown the door.
"This is just AI slop"
If you suspect a post/comment is AI, please -report- it (rule 9). Do not comment on it being AI as that just helps the spammers win. We will get to it and if it is AI, we will nuke it with glee.
So yeah. Everybody be cool, alright?
Thanks again to all the good folks and my fellow super nerds who make this a fun place to talk about our favorite hobby. We greatly appreciate you.
TTFN.