You Always Look Like This
You act like you don’t know what I mean when I stare,
Like you’re just some tired man standing there.
But I tell you you’re beautiful and you laugh it away,
Like it’s something I wouldn’t say.
I say it again, softer this time,
And your black coffee pauses halfway to your lips,
Like even your doubt starts to slip.
You say, “Don’t start that,” like you need me to stop,
But your eyes don’t leave mine when I don’t.
Those crinkles by your eyes show up when you try,
Like your guard never quite learns how to lie.
And I step in closer like I already know,
Like I’ve seen the exact way you’re going to go.
And your voice goes quieter, like it forgets what to do,
When I say, “I really like looking at you.”
That’s when your hand finds my waist like it’s automatic,
Like you didn’t mean it but it still happened.
We kiss like we’ve been circling this too long,
Like every little look was already wrong.
Slow at first, like you’re still not sure you can,
Like you forgot you’re a man who can.
Then you give in; just a shift, just a change,
Like something in you finally stops trying to behave.
And I pull you in closer like I’ve always known,
This is where all your softness is shown.
And I smile into it like I knew from the start,
You’d stop trying to keep me apart.
When we break for a second, you don’t move away,
Just stay too close, and in a quieter way,
You say, “You shouldn’t look at me like that,”
But you don’t mean it, not after that.
And I tell you again, like it’s simple and true,
“You always look like this when I’m with you.”