u/bouldytherock

I dont see much agenda posting from most Hashira and or upper rank fans, so im curious how they are like. Are there any major "agenda wars" like Giyu and Sanemi or Tengen and Shinobu?

Do people even consider themselves agenda pushers? Who does the sub consider each characters best agenda pusher and or scaler?

And or who are considered each characters worse scaler? Be it a downplayer or glazer (you dont have to answer unless you want to, and if you do try not to be rude about it)

SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT THESE TWO. GLAZE THEIR WRITING. STOP MENTIONING BOTH OF THEM IN THE SAME MATCH UP FOR AT LEAST 2 DAYS. WE HAVE OTHER CHARACTERS FOR A REASON

Hopefully i didnt miss anyone

For the actual ranking its

1. Tengen – a well written character, fought my favorite upper rank, really cool fighting style, bombs, everything you can ever want. I love his duality on how hes loud yet humble, isnt arrogant, wishes to distance himself feom his troubled past. And an underrated aspect is how his backstory isnt "Demons did this to me so Muzans gotta die". He just wants to help people and atone for what he believes to be his mistakes for killing his siblings. I loved his interaction with Ubuyashiki too. And his relationship with his wives is also a really good aspect of his character, telling them to value their lives over his

2. Gyomei – underrated writing wise, again, i love his fighting style and his weapons, i enjoyed his interactions with Kokushibo, telling him to kick rocks when he tried to assert his worldview over him, him ragebaiting him, honoring Muichiro and Genya as they passed, and putting in work, him warming up to tanjiro during the HTA. And him peacedully passing away during the end was a nice ending to his character

3. Sanemi – well written. His dynamic with Genya was nice, i especially enjoyed his development after the koku fight, and especially with how he treated nezuko at the end of the series. An amazing character who i warmed up to over time.

4. Rengoku/Shinobu – leaning more towards Shinobu. 2nd best written female character in the series (behind Tamayo of course). I loved her story, her revenge on douma was perfect, and her plan on how to kill him was too.

5. Shinobu/Rengoku – rengoku is rengoku

6. Giyu – not much to say about him, i never really minded him all too much. I guess i enjoyed the akaza fight and what he did during sunrise countdown. His inferiority complex and survivors guilt are interesting. I might move him above Rengoku should i warm up to him

7. Mitsuri/Obanai – Obanai is better as a character but im giving a simillar point i gave Tengen to Mitsuri about the backstory. Plus Obanai did a few things i didnt really like which i will get to. Mitsuri got screwed by the story though. Overall carried by SSVA. Mitsuri and Obanai deserved better

8. Obanai/Mitsuri – inserting your backstory mid sunrise countdown was a mistake. Should have done more beforehand. The snake and sword carries. He saddens me because he geniunely could have gotten so much more, but no.

9. Muichiro – i feel nothing towards this guy. Hes just there. Bum for being related to Kokushibo.

I think ive managed to get Tengen's details down. Akaza is chopped but i had a difficult angle to work with. But overall, im happy with it. Added my own few touches as well

Tengen belts this deadbeat BUM.

You can all have this while i formulate the Tengen glaze post

Shinobu keeps her sword and poison, and if Tengen grips her shoes hard enough she can turn bright red and act as a red blade. Where does this scale them?

As the founder of the Alliance, i found it necessary to list all the current members of the Alliance. If anyone new turns up or if anyone decides to leave, i will add/remove them to/from this specific post. As of now, the alliance is composed of the following:

u/bouldytherock (me)

u/NeitherChemistry9954

u/LevyMcgarden123

u/Pooninkle

u/Existingcomposer4555

u/RingEducational6355

u/Yousucktaken2

u/Dscdrivercpm-fr

u/Vergil_Raptor

u/AnyRace4443

u/confused-overwhelmed

u/Kago-

u/King3azy_gaming

u/ConsciousLetter6588

If im known for anything or any specific takes, lay em on me as well.

I had to repost this due to reddit being ass and voiding my first one

To those who read this, drumless Kyogai>Prime, marked, red blade, stw Michikatsu

If any of my takes are popular, im curious which ones

Due to the agreement of not slandering Tengen and Shinobu between the sides (at least whoever actually is in the alliance), we have to decide what is considered "glaze" and "downplay" for our Hashira.

​

Another thing, as per rules, we arent allowed to slander Shinobu and Tengen. However if lets say a Tengen fan also likes Giyu, and a Shinobu fan slanders Giyu, that wont count as a breach of the treaty. The alliance only applies to those 2 specific Hashira. Another thing, if a Shinobu fan say slanders Tengen, but said fan isnt the alliance, it wont count as a breach of the treaty and vice versa.

​

If one wishes to purpose the rules of the alliance, they may give their opinion on it. We also eventually have to decide a scale for both of them.

​

Also both Tengen and Shinobu brutalize a marked, STW, red blade, musical score, death amped Michikatsu

It has been long since both our goats have been downplayed to hell and back, and the constant fighting between the 2 parties has resulted in nothing but needless slander wars, while the other Hashira get off relatively free.

I purpose an alliance, a common goal we both share is to have our respective Hashira to recieve the respect they deserve. Thus, i do not see why we should not band together. Both Tengen and Shinobu recieve an extreme amount of slander (mostly from eachother), but that need not be this way.

Thus, through this alliance, i will cease my slander of Shinobu, and pardon all those among your people who have stained Tengens name. I will see Shinobu's scales, and grant her the grace she lacked from others. In turn, i ask the same to be done to Tengen.

2 of the most wasted upper ranks

Lets assume every Hashira here is marked, and Obanai's frail bones dont shatter under the weight of Shinobu standing on top of him