Roast me before I kill this: nobody who opens the page will press the button
I built The Boardroom. You paste in a piece of work, five critics argue about it, and you give you honest feedback. First answer is free, no signup. $29 once for 100 after that.
This isn't for AI super users. But I've shared it with about 20 people, and no one has even tried it. One person shared good feedback, one of them was that he isn't the demo for this.
Not one person ran a answer. My friends were too nice to tell me why, which is the exact thing the product claims to fix, so it is funny in a way.
I rebuilt the page yesterday. The paste box used to sit almost two screens down on a phone. It is on the first screen now, and there are one-tap prompts, because I finally worked out that nobody tapping a link in a text message is holding a pitch deck in their clipboard.
Let me get the obvious one out of the way, since this sub has a rule about it. Yes there is AI under this, and yes you could paste your work into a free chatbot and tell it to be harsh. My argument is that one voice agreeing with you is worth less than five that disagree with each other, and that the prompts are 15 years of knowing where work actually dies. That may be a distinction only I care about. Tell me if it is.
What I want roasted, in order:
The page. Does it make you want to try it, or close the tab?
The answer I just gave. Is "five voices that argue" worth anything, or is it a feature nobody asked for?
If the honest answer is that this should not exist, say that. I have a date at the end of the October where I decide whether to keep going.