AITA for telling my close friend that her best friend told people about her homeschooling?
I (16F) have a close friend, who I’ll call A (16F). A also has a best friend, S (15M). They’ve been best friends since A was 14, so obviously they’re much closer than A and I are.
A has a pretty serious heart condition and was in hospital for quite a while because of it. When she came back, she had a meeting with the school, and eventually it was decided that she would be homeschooled because of her condition.
A is also pretty particular about who she’s friends with. She’s had issues with people not respecting her boundaries, so she’s very careful about who she trusts.
Me, A and S are all in the same English class. There are three girls in the class who A has had issues with, and we all know they talk behind her back. I’m not friends with these girls and don’t really talk to them.
S, however, talks to them. He says that because he’s friends with one of them, he has to talk to all three. A doesn’t actually care that S talks to people she doesn’t like, and neither do I. That’s not the issue.
The issue is that before those girls even came into class, I specifically told S that if anyone asked where A was, not to tell them she was being homeschooled. I wasn’t telling him to lie or anything dramatic , just say she was away or that he didn’t know.
Well, one of those girls asked S where A was.
And S literally told her that A was being homeschooled. Apparently, he then told pretty much everyone else who asked too.
I found out and obviously told A because I felt like she had a right to know that people were being told about something personal involving her.
Later, I got home and S texted me. We ended up arguing back and forth about the whole situation. At one point he started coming at me about my makeup, which had absolutely nothing to do with the argument. I made a comment about his weight in response, which I know wasn’t exactly mature, but it shut the argument down. I also told him that if I tell A what happened at school and he ends up looking like the bad guy, that’s not because I’m trying to make him look bad. It’s because of the things he actually did.
Now I’m pretty sure he’s going to tell almost everyone in our class about the argument.
Honestly, I don’t really care anymore.
But now I’m wondering if I was actually wrong for telling A what he said. I wasn’t trying to start drama or get A angry at him. I just thought she deserved to know that S was telling people about her situation after I’d specifically asked him not to.
So, AITA?