
I'm building a guitar interface/processor with up to 4 NAM A2-full models plus effects and can't decide the form factor. Which would you actually use?
Hi everyone. Having fed up with the poor quality in current guitar interfaces and effects processors, I've decided to build my own. I recently built firmware for a $3 chip that can run a NAM A2 Full and a cab plus 6 effects. You can read more about it here on this thread.
I decided to put it in a physical form factor, and having played guitar and owned tens of pedals in the last 25 years, I'm quite undecided about what would be the best form factor. So I'd like input from people who actually play through this kind of gear.
What it does: a guitar in (stereo so you can use break out cables), stereo out, a headphone out and USB-C audio to a computer. It runs up to 20 blocks of effects, including analog guitar synth and (hopefully, I'm still working on it) guitar to MIDI, plus up to 4 A2-Full captures and up to 8 A2-Lite captures on two DSP chips. You switch presets from the unit; editing happens in an app. Latency is around 2.6-3ms with the full chain on (~1ms when used as a direct interface), and I use a high-end ADC with 119dB dynamic range—trying to get it to a world class interface.
The three shapes I'm considering:
The three different shapes I'm thinking of
- Desk/handheld interface, iRig HD X style. About 49 × 104 mm, battery powered, a big knob and three buttons. Lives next to your laptop or can be used on stage either hanging free from your gitar, or maybe even with a clip attached to your guitar strap.
- Guitar-mounted, like a Roland GK control unit. A thin box fixed to the guitar body with a short cable to the jack. Headphones and USB plug into it, so you practise or go on stage with no cables to the floor. It unclips to sit on a desk. May be battery powered.
- Mini floor pedal, Tonex One / Hammond 1590B size. 9 V DC in or USB power, one footswitch, a couple of knobs. Goes on a pedalboard, but also works on a desk.
I myself lean towards a guitar mount, for whatever reason I'm still in love with the old Roland GK-3.
What I'd love to know:
- Where do you play most: couch, desk, pedalboard or rehearsal and gigs?
- Would you mount this unit on your guitar? What would put you off (weight, finish, cables)?
- Battery or 9 V: does battery power matter to you for something like this?
- If it's a pedal, how many footswitches is the minimum: one for bypass, or two for presets?
- Anything you hate about the Tonex One, Mustang Micro, iRig or similar that a new box should fix?
- Would you prefer a small screen vs several LEDs to indicate presets?
- What other features would you like to see?
Full disclosure: I'm the one building it. I'm not selling anything yet; I'm just trying not to build the wrong shape.
Edit: It will support Bluetooth MIDI by default. In which scenarios would you be interested in a physical MIDI input?