
u/eddjc

Contemporary Music for All, a wonderful if slightly flawed movement
[effacé]
The hidden classism of the UK Composition scene
Detailed, obsessive and consolidated artistic identities take time, expertise, networking and visibility to accrue, and all of that costs money.
Realising the inevitability of your own compositional voice
You never quite know what you look like to other people- how you come across. So why would you know what your compositional voice is?
https://eddjc.substack.com/p/realising-the-inevitability-of-your
My generation of composers were given opportunities to work for free while musicians get paid handsomely. In a project that probably cost £14k to produce, I got nothing.
I know that this description of the classical music group is tongue in cheek, but it signals a culture that I really detest in classical music. I've performed the most exquisite choral music across mainland China, and without fail the audiences were chewing, spitting, talking and applauding. Without fail we were treated as heroes and given loud applause and standing ovations.
Yes, it's irritating to be in the middle of a quiet bit and hear the rustle of a wrapper. No, I don't think people should be restricted from doing so. I believe that it's a relatively new phenomenon, and if anything it's the duty of the performer to command the audience and engage them, such that they don't stir in their seats, not that the audience should be cowed into submission by their fellow concert goers.
If there's anything that performers enjoy, it's spontaneous applause. Yes, if that then becomes expected between every movement regardless of merit, then it can be irksome. No, I don't think people should be shushed. I think it puts people off.
/rant
Musicians often snub amateur music making—but amateur musicians are the audience, the workforce, and the ecosystem that classical music depends on.
It's a mistake to imagine that there are "schools" of composers. We're not fish, we don't swim together.
Many encounters in my professional life involve watching someone retreat backwards quickly out of a door when I explain my MU sanctioned rates. Are those rates unreasonable?