r/classicalmusic

Oct 12: Birthday of Sylvius Leopold Weiss (1687–1750).
▲ 21 r/classicalmusic+1 crossposts

Oct 12: Birthday of Sylvius Leopold Weiss (1687–1750).

The greatest lutenist of his time, and the friend of Bach. What do we actually have of that friendship?

The documents give us one visit. In the summer of 1739 Weiss came to Leipzig with his pupil Kropffgans and stayed four weeks at Bach's house. Bach's relative Johann Elias Bach wrote that there had been "something extra fine in music."

The famous story of the two of them improvising fantasias and fugues against each other comes later. Johann Friedrich Reichardt published it in 1805, more than sixty years after the visit, on the word of people who said they had been there.

The trace you can actually hear is BWV 1025. Bach took Weiss's Lute Sonata in A major, kept the lute part almost as it was for the harpsichord, and wrote a violin part over it.

Last year someone here told me Weiss once said he had spent half his life tuning his lute. I couldn't find that. What I did find is an older joke about all lutenists, credited to Mattheson: a lutenist who lives to eighty has spent sixty years tuning.

Bach: Suite in A major for violin and lute, BWV 1025 (after Weiss)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIWKKY1iMEs

Weiss: Lute Sonata in D minor
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PW4ppQKmehI

u/Little_Grapefruit636 — 3 days ago

One-hit wonders

I'm wondering which composers you believe may fall into this category. For example, I'm sure Berlioz has many great pieces, but when I hear his name I'm sure I'm not alone in associating it with really just one piece. Please share

reddit.com
u/greengoblin18 — 6 days ago

What’s the point of the New Complexity movement?

First off, I want to say that I don’t judge anyone who really likes this type of music. Art is subjective after all. That being said, to me, I don’t get why one would compose a piece that would alienate both an audience and the performer. First of all, most audiences are not likely going to be inclined to hear a piece that to most people sounds like a cat walking on the piano. Secondly, most performers wouldn’t want to pour hours into learning an overcomplicated, ridiculously difficult piece just for at best, no one to listen to it and at worst, to be ridiculed for playing it. So what’s exactly the point of the ridiculous complexity and lack of structure? If I said anything wrong here, please let me know.

reddit.com
u/Healthy_Writing3649 — 5 days ago

If I really like The Trout and Mendelssohns Octet, what other works would you recommend to me, by them or other composers? Especially if you have a specific recording in mind.

Thank you and have a great weekend

reddit.com
u/UmweltUndefined — 5 days ago

Who are the most performed living classical composers?

Just wondering if there is somewhere where I can find a list of the most frequently performed living composers in the repertoire. Basically I'm trying to find a list of the most popular composers today going by stats. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

reddit.com
u/Designer-Share-9733 — 6 days ago

Feeling insecure about my taste

Hello, I know this might seem stupid to some of y'all but it's really been bugging me recently, I feel kind of weird with how much I love classical music, I especially love the baroque and romantic period, the problem is that I'm starting to doubt myself of why is such old music my favorite. The insecurity especially hits when people ask what kind of music I enjoy and I feel awkward saying classical, I'd say what bugs me most is how old it is, even other music genres I love like jazz and soul are mostly albums from the 50s to the 70s or something like that.
Do any of you guys feel this way? Especially if you are young, how did you overcome this feeling?

Edit: thanks y'all for the kind words, my problem isn't so much that my taste doesn't aline with my friends, it's that I feel weird liking music so old, like I wish my music taste wasn't frozen in a very old period.

reddit.com
u/JoJo_Starrr — 7 days ago

"Golden age of stereo" Myth or Real?

When I got into classical I got recommended DG like I assume everyone else, later I learned about BIS (my favorite) and Hyperion whom I get most of my music, but recently I've been hearing more and more about how labels from the 50s to 60s made some of the best sounding records ever, I assumed bs at first but after listening to some Decca and RCA I'd say they are far better than any other music recorded in that time, but honestly I still think that modern recordings sound better, though my headphones aren't the very best.

What do you y'all think? those who have good playback systems which one do you prefer? Does the quality of those record unlock the better your gear is?

reddit.com
u/JoJo_Starrr — 5 days ago

What are your thoughts on the Impressionist era?

People don't talk enough about the genius of Claude Debussy or Maurice Ravel as much as they should. Ravel's Gaspard de la Nuit is one of the hardest things written for piano, and so different musically. Debussy was a master of color, and hiding the rhythm in his music.

Also were there any other impressionist composers besides these 2? I'm sure there are, but please let me know of any you know and like. And your thought about this era.

reddit.com
u/Excellent_Heat_6336 — 6 days ago

Oct 9: Birthday of Einojuhani Rautavaara (1928–2016).

Cantus Arcticus was meant to be a choral piece. In 1971 the University of Oulu asked him for a cantata for its first doctoral ceremony. He couldn't find any poems he liked, and the choir was overworked and not in good voice, so he wrote for birds instead, using recordings from the Finnish radio's archive and from the marshes near Oulu.

I'm listening to it as I write this. It's a fascinating piece, one that could reach people who don't usually listen to classical music, and it has something healing about it.

A Japanese reader told me this week that it is one of the most popular contemporary pieces in Europe, and on the radio all the time.

Cantus Arcticus, Op. 61 (Max Pommer, Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TO3YRZWLvQo

u/Little_Grapefruit636 — 6 days ago

How to get into Parsifal?

My first foray into Wagner's music was maybe 25 years ago when I bought a recording of Die Walküre (Haitink). Loved it then and still love it now. There's a reason it's the most popular and most frequently performed of his operas. I then bought Haitink's Götterdämmerung and loved that too. I was a skint student at the time and although, in my head, I was always going to buy the rest of Haitink's Ring cycle, lack of funds got in the way and I never got the other two.

Fast forward a decade or two and I found myself singing in the chorus of a performance of Tannhäuser at the St. Endellion Music Festival. I was completely wowed by the whole experience. The overture might be a concert favourite but for the maximum emotional effect try singing that glorious tune at the end of the whole opera. Unforgettable.

Having now had a proper job for a while I don't have the same restriction on CD-buying I had when I was a student and have recently got hold of the Solti ring cycle. I was a bit sceptical that something from the late 50s and early 60s could be the greatest recording of all time. Then I listened to it. They were right. It is.

After that I set about further expanding my knowledge of Wagner and bought recordings of Tristan und Isolde and Lohengrin, both of which I've very much enjoyed, especially Tristan.

Most recently I got a recording of Parsifal (Gergiev), and this is where I (finally) come to the point of my post because I'm struggling to get to grips with it.

I feel sure this a me problem rather than a Wagner problem, so I'd appreciate any suggestions you might have about how to approach this opera. Do I just need to hear a different recording? I love Wagner's orchestral writing so perhaps I need to hear a version where the orchestra kicks ass more? I just don't know. Let know know what you think!

reddit.com
u/Valuable_Turnover219 — 5 days ago

Recommend pieces like Shostakovich's Piano Concerto in F major's second movement, slightly sentimental but gorgeous and kind of wounded?

I've been listening to a lot of 20th century string quartets, all angles and tension, and somehow stumbled via Reddit onto this piece, and I'm kind of mildly obsessed with its melody and form.

I know it's maybe borderline sentimental, but it's really beautiful to me.

Are there other pieces that share a similar kind of direct emotionalness that you like? I know some might feel that way about Arvo Pärt or Barber, any others really appreciated! Thank you!

reddit.com
u/Annathelma — 6 days ago

Pieces for celesta solo?

I played the celesta for the first time in my life in a large concert hall, Strauss Alp Symphony. I enjoyed playing a lot. I am wondering whether there are some compositions for celesta solo? I would like to explore this instrument more.

reddit.com
u/Alarmed_Tadpole_7618 — 6 days ago

What makes this specific passage of Schubert's D.887 quartet so effective?

I can't read music but this specific passage of D.887 really hits me everytime. It's like heavens opening up then there's sudden storm. How does this specific passage do that..

Recording: Quartett Italiano

u/winterreise_1827 — 7 days ago

Friday Recommendation 4U

I had zero idea who Dobrawa Czocher was until I found this album and tbh this one is on the top 5 classical albums of 2026, the music is not just beautiful but also has this vibe that makes your body chill, this is a great album and she’s actually an amazing composer, so do yourself a favor and listen to it, I hope you guys like it!! 💕

https://open.spotify.com/album/1RQhwZ60qkrdKHqES84CKn?si=dqIQE9U3TsKiLHPmiseVcA

Also if you want to buy it here’s the link

https://dobrawaczocher.bandcamp.com/album/state-of-matter

u/sstarlight_q — 6 days ago
▲ 21 r/classicalmusic+1 crossposts

Trying to curate 14 half-hour playlists for a person with dementia

Hi there

I'm looking to curate calming and soothing classical music (preferably piano-driven though it's not a must) for a family member who sadly is battling severe Alzheimer's. My intention is to have 14 half-hour separate playlists, two for each day playing in the morning and afternoon hours respectively.

I know that Mozart and Bach have always been a hit for her, so obviously I'm gonna go digging for a lot of works in those repertoires. But I'm looking for tips, pointers and recommendations in similar energies and moods.
Preferably airy, somewhat light and major-key leaning. I'm also putting in the odd Brian Eno-track here and there, because I think some of his Ambient-album works also fit the bill of evoking tranquility and a sense of ease and belonging.

Any help would be greatly appreciated. It's quite the task to amass seven hours of music where I want (almost) every second to really count.

Thanks in advance to all who reply

reddit.com
u/MatPassion — 8 days ago

Does anyone have a recording of this peice!

I have been looking for a recording of this piece and I can’t find one anywhere! the counting gets pretty difficult for me and I just need to hear it.

if anyone has a recording or knows where to find one please let me know.

edit: I realize that I misspelled piece in the title 😅

u/Charming-Process7898 — 6 days ago
▲ 5 r/classicalmusic+1 crossposts

Would it be too much to ask for some feedback on a classical music website?

I recently started CT Chamber Collective to help people discover classical and chamber music concerts around Connecticut.

Would it be too much to ask you all to take a look and tell me what you think?

https://ctchambercollective.com

I'm especially curious whether the site makes it easy to find concerts and what you think is missing.

Appreciate any honest feedback!

reddit.com
u/shokaru — 7 days ago