
Bench players
Amassing a sizeable collection of mechpens means they're not all gonna be winners. Here are the ones I keep in a pencil case in my drawer plus the reasons why I don't use them.
– The Faber-Castells don't match the build quality of the TK-Fine Vario L. The Executive was an NOS unit that feels light, wobbly and too plastic-y; the 9715 feels very cheap and there's a scratchy feel to the way it advances the lead.
– The pink Paper Mate was bought more out of nostalgia (it was a popular brand among Brazilian schoolkids) than anything else, and I was motivated to get the Sharpwriter because of a video where Adam Savage swears by them (they're trash).
– My issues with the Koh-I-Noor are their grips: the Mephisto's rubber grip is sticky and unpleasant and the Rapidomatic's knurling is just extremely coarse (even worse than the Staedtler 925 25/35's... someone should make a list ranking knurled grips by level of coarseness).
– The same applies to the knurled grip of the Mono Graph Zero, but the paint started to peel off so I would have spared it even if it had a good hand feel.
– The LEGO mechpen is a joke of a pencil and I regret spending my money on it. Absolute garbage.
– I bought the Kaco Coca-Cola pencils out of curiosity because they were dirt cheap and was surprised to find brass clutches, but ended up never using them because they are very light and rattle-y.
Now for the Pentels.
– The Pentel Graph Rocks are just Sharps with a different tip, and since I already have 60+ P200 pencils in rotation I just chose to keep these two stored away.
– The Graphlet feels very cheap in spite of its classic design.
– It's a shame I can't stand the way the PG5 looks, because it's got incredible internals. Every time I look at it all I see is Bert from Sesame Street.
– I got the Forte under the premise that it was an NOS unit, but it arrived here damaged: the lead refused to advance from the clutch to the pipe. When I unscrewed the tip, a tiny little plastic piece fell out of it, then I put it back together and now the lead just slides down the pipe and out of the pencil when I try to advance it.
– I got a killer deal on the last Technica-X ever available for sale in Brazil (R$ 3, or about $0.58) and it is incredibly well-built, but the body feels awkward when writing.
– As for the rest of them — Sharplet, Caplet, Techniclicks, Hot Shots, Jolt, Quicker Clicker, Quick Click, Prime and the A525 — they just all felt very light and cheap.