What is an unfixed broken TV in a furnished rental worth in terms of rent reduction? And a rant about a PM asking us to act in “goodfaith”
I just left a rental property. PM found a stain on the carpet that a professional carpet cleaner couldn’t remove. I caused the stain. Landlord got a quote for $1500 to re-carpet the room. The stain isn’t that bad, I wouldn’t bother replacing the carpet if it were me but whatever. The PM sent us an email asking for a ‘goodfaith’ contribution to the replacement without stating a figure. I replied saying “show me an invoice when the carpets were last replaced” as I suspect it’s more than ten years ago and therefore legally worth zero dollars. However in the circumstance they provide evidence they were replaced say 5 years ago I want to counter by saying you never fixed the broken TV that was included in our rent for ~12 months. What would be the monetary value of not having access to the TV? We replaced with our own and took it with us when we left.
Now the rant - We as tenants genuinely acted in “good faith” through the tenancy - fixed minor plumbing issues ourselves, didn’t complain when they refused to fix broken doors, endured weekly open homes for 9 months as the property is for sale (still unsold), always cleaning before the open homes. Seems goodfaith only applies to our behaviour, not theirs. So I’m loath to hand over money when they wont even replace the carpet and just sell the property with a stain.