u/lisbot84

Does anyone know about the EML merch on Etsy that says “licensed”? Is that legit? It’s the shop called For Wednesday’s Child.

Anyone else completely stop watching after the season >!3 finale?!< I’m so >!devastated about Matthew’s death,!< I don’t even want to watch the show anymore. I started season >!4!< just to >!confirm he’s gone!< and turned it off. Anyone else? Should I keep going? Is it worth it?

Anyone have any theories about the 1916 Gazette? Beth says it’s a dialogue between two characters we have yet to meet. Curious about theories of who is taking and who are they talking about!

Anyone know the order of the Gazettes or does order not matter? I’ve just been scrolling all the way through her Substack to the next up from the bottom and it’s getting annoying!

I am curious the average age range of fellow Lionhearts on Reddit! Totally anonymous of course!

View Poll

Curious if anyone has read the books corresponding with the month of the year in real life. For example reading the August entries in August, etc. or even day to day. And if anyone would be interested in doing it with me!?

Anyone know what date or estimated date Stonecrop was established? Or just a best guess? Asking because I’m making myself a sweatshirt with my Cricut (no profit, just for fun!) I’m also gonna make a St. Crispian’s one eventually so I’ll need the date for that too. I’ll put a rough draft in the comments!

WHY doesn’t he talk to Emma? Isn’t there something odd about that, him only sending messages through Agnes and Hawks?
WHY is he not in Volumes 7-8?? Where did he go?
I have no theories so give me yours!

I’m curious about EML fans in general. Do you guys tend to have the “fan girl” (or boy) personalities about things you love? Or is EML just that good? Or both!
I, for example, tend to obsess over all my interests. But I am typically not a re-reader, re-watcher or re-listener (songs, yes but not audiobooks). There are very few exceptions, even for my absolute favorites. Emma is one of the few. I find it so captivating! So I wonder- is it just my personality to obsess, or is just the sheer genius of these books that has people hooked!

(Edit- I realize this post is more introspective/reader centered rather than about the series itself. Feel free to remove if not appropriate for this sub!)

Hello! Will people comment in here some important dates in Emma’s life or dates of favorite journal entries? I’m collecting a list because I’m making a calendar 🤪

Examples would be when she met certain characters, different characters birthdays, when she had important conversations, stuff like that!! Really anything!

I’m curious to hear everyone’s predictions about when we’re getting Volume 9 (and even other future releases!)
I know we cannot rush perfection, I just want to daydream!

Why do so many people think Pierce had something to do with Maxwell’s death?!? I can’t bear to think that!! Is it because he has a picture of Maxwell? Explain this to me like I’m 5 because I don’t get it.

I’m curious! What’s your favorite scene in the books so far? What about the funniest scene in your opinion?
I’m trying to relive some moments from this amazing series while we wait for volume 9!
I’ll go first- my favorite is when all her boys take care of her after Maxwell’s funeral. Alchemy at work in the best way! The funniest is when Mrs. Penury gets trapped behind the door at LLH when Islington bursts in to confront Emma, and the entire convo that follows with her listening.

Anyone have a good drawing or visual for the layout of Stonecrop? I have the hardest time picturing it!

I’ve been working on a “digital scrapbook” of sorts, kinda like a mood board. I’ve been having so much fun with it! Not sure if it’s considered fan art. Anyways, where would be a good place to share it?

I hope I’m not overstepping here! I know I am new here, but has there ever been talk of making discussion threads for different love interest preferences and theories (general admirations lol!) The only reason I ask is because in general discussions I love to connect with other people who share my hopes for Emma (and a particular handsome photographer!!!) I am always looking for certain usernames who I know tend to share my opinion and thought it would be fun to get us all together in a thread. Is that too much!??

Repost—
*Spoilers ahead* Just want to preface this by saying I am 100000% team Pierce and I hope against all odds that he is endgame for Emma. Now that being said, I am concerned they aren’t going to make it. I have this gnawing feeling that BB is setting up Hawkes to be endgame. Just with his connection to Declan (and being her guardian), her possibly being the Titania to his Oberon (strong enough to break the curse- as evidenced by her holding his book hostage and making him come back after David v Goliath), the fountain scene, the fact that she didn’t recognize the footsteps of Pierce in her vision. There’s a lot of foreshadowing about Pierce leaving and Hawkes being a stable foundation. I believe he is one of the branches spoken of in the prophecy and I fear that’s the direction she will take! Please prove me wrong!!!

So, do we all pretty much agree Oberon is Hawkes?? If so- do we think Lady Eloise Silver is the one he danced with? Emma describes them similarly. The Boy says Oberon is cursed and this woman isn’t his Titania because she isn’t strong enough to break the curse- perhaps Emma is? This may already be a popular theory. I’m new to the series, I’ve just finished Volume 8. Apologies if this is in the wrong thread!