He (28M) had an emotional affair with his new gym friend (27F)
TL;DR: My boyfriend emotionally leaned on another woman during a difficult time, hid parts of their relationship from me, and now I’m struggling with whether I can rebuild trust after 5 years together.
I (30F) have been with my boyfriend “Ryan” (28M) for 5 years and honestly thought I was going to marry him. We already had the ring and everything and he was going to propose this summer. I trusted him more than anyone. I always described him as the safest, kindest person I knew.
A few weeks ago his grandpa passed away very suddenly and it completely wrecked him emotionally. Around the same time, a new girl in our friend group (we’d known her for a few months at that point) “Katy” (27F) had also lost someone close to her. My boyfriend has always had a huge caretaker personality and tends to throw himself into helping people, especially emotionally vulnerable people.
At first I actually became friends with her too. We would text, talk, confide in each other, etc. I comforted her in her time of grief. But over time I started getting a really weird feeling about how emotionally close she and “Ryan” were becoming. They also started going to the gym with a group of our other friends during the evenings. My schedule did not allow me to join this group, so they spent a lot of time together without me. They would go to dinner with the group almost every week night, and he wouldn’t come home until like 9pm. They started texting, emotional venting, her leaning on him heavily, him prioritizing helping her constantly. I asked him to start coming home earlier and communicated my discomfort to him multiple times and he kept insisting nothing inappropriate was happening and that he was “just helping her.”
The thing that hurts so much is that I understand grief deeply myself. Two years ago I lost both my dad and one of my close friends within about a year of each other. So watching the two of them emotionally lean on each other while completely shutting me out hurt in a way I can’t even explain. It genuinely started feeling like I was outside of my own relationship while another woman became his emotional support person. I was heartbroken for him and wanted to help so badly, but felt like I was being shut out.
Something I should mention is that I was recently diagnosed with severe OCD. I had been struggling with a bad flair up for months prior to this and had withdrawn from many people in my life, including my boyfriend. He had communicated this to me, and I realized that I needed help, so I sought treatment. I admit and take full responsibility for avoiding it for so long and not communicating with him about it. I know it made him lonely for a while. I realize that this is relevant to the situation.
But, I started to feel like “Katy” was realizing how much “Ryan” was willing to do for his friends and started to ask for his help outside of the boundaries that his other friends would. Like, we NEVER had this issue before her. There were also a bunch of weird moments that piled up over time. One that still really bothers me is when we were at a party, my boyfriend offered me his jacket one night because I was cold, but it didn’t fit me (I am a plus sized girl) so I gave it back. Sometimes his jackets fit me, sometimes they don’t. She saw this happen. She happens to be thinner than me. I walked away to talk to another friend, and a few seconds later, she put his jacket on herself, gave him hers, told him to put it on, grabbed him and ran over to me while I was talking to another friend and excitedly went “Look! We switched jackets!” while pulling him behind her and smiling hugely. He looked guilty and clearly failed to set any boundaries with her. He denied that it was weird until much later on. Maybe it sounds dumb but it honestly felt weirdly territorial and humiliating. It even felt like she body checked me, to be completely honest.
Then as she got closer to him, she basically stopped talking to me entirely. We had been becoming friends too, and suddenly it was just radio silence from her while she got emotionally closer to my boyfriend. I kept telling him that he was seeing a side of her that she wasn’t showing me, but he kept insisting that she would always speak highly of me and really liked me. He wouldn’t listen when I told him my intuition was telling me something about her was off.
About 3 weeks ago everything exploded because I found out he had been lying to me about how emotionally attached he had become to her. I found out that they were texting when he told me they weren’t. Also calling each other. As far as I know nothing physical happened (I caught him texting her and demanded to read their texts. They were emotional and frequent, but nothing inherently romantic or sexual— mostly checking in on each other, having emotional/intimate conversations about their grief and sharing pictures of what they were doing or eating throughout the day… every day). He is extremely adamant that nothing physical happened. But during that time, he had reassured me that they were not speaking to each other. The worst part is we were literally already in couples therapy while he was still hiding a lot of the truth from me.
When I confronted her, she acted like she had no idea she was causing problems in my relationship and implied she didn’t realize boundaries were being crossed, but my boyfriend later admitted she DID know there was tension between us and she was the cause. He literally told her and she still continued to reach out to him and ask for emotional support. She also told me that she was “concerned I was setting restrictions on who she can and can’t communicate with and how.” I told her that the only person I was restricting her from was my partner of 5 years and blocked her. He had also already blocked her on everything.
Now my boyfriend is devastated and horrified. He keeps saying he thought he was helping someone broken while he himself was grieving and emotionally falling apart too. He admitted he got trapped in lies and kept rationalizing/compartmentalizing everything instead of confronting how attached he had become. He said he justified it because nothing romantic was going on and he felt like I was overthinking it. He genuinely thought he could help her while also maintaining our relationship. He has taken full responsibility for everything and is in therapy now trying to work on boundaries and conflict avoidance.
The complicated part is I still love him deeply. We still live together, but I moved into the loft. For 5 years, we have been the best of friends. He has always treated me in the most kind and loving way. He would do absolutely anything for me. We still spend time together and laugh together and honestly sometimes it feels almost normal. Then suddenly I remember I was supposed to marry this person and now I don’t even recognize my own life anymore.
I don’t see him the same way. I trusted him completely before this and now I question everything. I feel embarrassed because all my friends knew how much I adored him and how excited I was for our future.
Part of me thinks he’s genuinely a good person who got himself into a really unhealthy emotional dynamic during a period of grief and handled it horribly. I was his first girlfriend and he hadn’t really ever gotten attention from other girls. He has grown into a very conventionally attractive man after being/feeling awkward his whole life. Another part of me feels like something permanently broke and I don’t know if I’ll ever fully trust him the same way again.
I honestly just feel exhausted and heartbroken and don’t know what’s normal anymore. I am giving myself some time to process everything before making any big decisions, but has anyone ever decided to stay after an emotional affair and did things get better?