For Leagues That Use Median Scoring. Would You Go Back?
Question for those of you who've switched to median scoring:
My league just voted to try it this season. I'm the commissioner, and while I wasn't really in favor of the change, enough people wanted to vote on it, so we did. The majority won.
My feeling has always been that median scoring doesn't really eliminate randomness, it just shifts where the randomness shows up. Instead of bad luck coming from your weekly matchup, it comes from whether you finish above or below the league median so it's fundamentally no different.
We're only using it during the regular season. Once the playoffs start, it'll go back to standard head-to-head matchups.
We're committed to giving it one full season before deciding whether to keep it. For those of you who've actually made the switch, did you end up liking it, or did you regret the change?
Was it worth it in the end?