odyssey- casting sucked-- but not how you think!!!
[Spoiler Alerts]
I think there were a few things wrong with the movie- so i actually walked out an hour early. It was late anyway, though i wasn't tired. I saw it in an IMAX even, the so called Laser Imax. Even before i went, when I had some higher expectations because my counsellor friend told me i would like it-- i still called it- the theater experience "platos cave"- going to watch projected shadows on the screen in a dark room.
So here's why my review is different and deeper- I couldn't care less about the race or ethnicity or trans-status of the actors as casted, nor even about historicity and faithfulness to the original poem. It is NOT about everything virtually every other critical reviewer yammers about but their EMOTIONAL PRESENCE and ACTING ABILITY. I can best explain by counter example- or loaded questioning.
Where are the likes of people Brian Cox, Eric Bana? Where is Sean Bean who played Ulixes in Troy of 2004 - which would have been good casting. Where are these type of guys, or even Russel Crowe or Mel Gibson or Joaquin Phoenix, or the guy who played Priam?
No one had precense, or even emotional continence. They had to externalize every thought and feeling they had the whole time. They had the 'tough guy' Menalaus- a fall from Brendan Gleeson's troy rendition- and had him get into a petty argument at the dinner banquet, a battle of wills or of seething resentment with his wife Helen and having him justify in front of guests why he did what he did. If the story (myth) indicates there's argument or criticism of characters, they can do it better, more wtih less. I actually just saw Devil Wears Prada for this first time this year, flying over the ocean, and started watching the 2026 sequel. My excuse and justification for bringing that up is that Ann Hathaway features in there like she plays Penelope- one of the better characters in Odyssey but mostly for lack of competition- though she is alright but in Devil Wears Prada she and Streep are great- they show continence- they do [much] more with [much] less. They are not infantile- in fact they are super-adult. Not to knock NY or elite professionals there- that is a tough world but one might expect a movie about Troy and the Odyssey to be the stronger tougher one- that but i guess it might be a mass appeal and accessibility thing- but then why has culture changed to necessitate this when movies of the last 100 years have even taught us how to be stable- look at Brando's Godfather or whatnot-- and look at the flack Sonny gets for 'expressing what he thinks' to Sollazo with a mere question of curiosity. I'm just trying to bring a small amount flack into the current era. This
There is no one like the man who played Priam, let alone Todd Armstrong or Michael Gwynn, who played Jason and Hermes respectively in Jason and the Argonauts from 63
Related - there's a lot of moralizing, self righteusness and then constant caving by the main characters- take Circe who turns the guys into swine. Such moralizing followed by apologizing- the recurring pattern- another modern western anachronism. I get that this may be for modern western accessibility so that people can identify with it but I don't know what changed, and it means they lose me- this viewer. Even before i went i felt like it was a chore- because i thought i should make time to see it in the famous IMAX (btw i'm only in my 40s- not a boomer) and I did get a little excited as it got closer to showing but i feel like movies are largely a joke- film is a joke or has not much of value to provide me- not in theater anyway. There are sometimes good things and maybe this is a function of changes both in me and in the industry but the industry has fallen i'm sure. It has fallen and when the bow breaks the cradle will fall. Makers of men; creators of leaders.. Sorry i got carried away by Al Pacinos speech in scent of a woman.
I'm not demanding perfection or what we had before but the casting is just emo and the scripting has everyone apologizing for everything always or justifying, and the others moralizing and presenting as wise when they don't prove that fact to me, to the viewer.
Another little thing that bothered me or that i noticed. It is not a movie that tries to draw you into its world by earning it- they had chances and it was high budget and great locations- but to force its world onto you, through noises, sounds, shakes etc- what i get just living where i live in a multifamily with construction around me. that is a fair approach but it has to earn it a little at least and not follow up with emotionality and sentimentality where i feel stabbed in the back. In contrast to trying to force itself into your mind with mindless 'action' sequences that do little for engaging me, and i don't expect it to be as extreme(ly amazing) as Jason and the Argonauts- I loved the scene that was very very short near the beginning where they showed the boat sailing westerward into the setting sun. That was beautiful and they showed it twice but briefly before they cut scened it to odysseus and penelope talking, emoting in bed. They could have lingered a bit longer- or a lot longer- especially since sailing is the vast majority of what they have to do. I'm actually reading a book on the birth of the athenian navy.
If you can summarize this review, tldr
I get that he tries to make it accessible but its over the top if i am to judge and if i am to not judge, it loses me- and i only went on recommendation from a trusted female friend, and so be it
Where is the Brian Cox like figure, Eric Bana, Priam and the like? Ya pin prick one of these current guys and they crumble. they guilt trip too. I didn't talk about that. Psychologists and sociologists would have a field day with this but NOBODY reviews things like this. They just talk politics and culture wars. They miss the bigger picture. "Has the whole world gone crazy? Am I the only one who ___"--- channeling Walter from the Big Lebowski now.
Verdict: overaccessibility killed. too much of a good thing is not a good thing. Μηδὲν ἄγαν - "Nothing in Excess"