u/squirrelycats

Sorry for the shaky screen! My hands have a mind of their own today I guess.

Given everything we have been chatting about in this sub the past week, this scene just has a different tone to me now. TFP seems to initiate things and doesn't know when to stop (i.e. Brayden getting his wood buffed in the Home Depot parking lot). Tate having spoken out finally about his side with his comments to Liann this week, saying he went along with it but then was uncomfortable and requested to stop. Miranda saying similar things. So rewatching this conversation Demi had, what was going through TFPs mind? A kiss on the head is pretty innocent on it's own but given the swinging context, obviously that changes things. I mean I personally don't kiss anyone on their head, only my husband, but some people are more forward. Demi states that she had been to parties and Brett got vibes from the husband's that there was swinging going on and he said he doesn't share.

I don't know, this whole show has a different look now with all of TFPs antics lately. And hearing some behind the scenes stuff going on. Am I the only one that wants to know more about this interaction? I feel like there is more there. And TFP being shameless with it all, just unburdened with the anchors of self respect and dignity (ayyeee VPR crossover), trying to be that girl, thinking everyone wants her. So much to unpack.

Newbies have entered the chat! Squirrelycats is back with the latest Dirty Deets installment.

I will continue updating this post because there is so much information, check back often to see updates. I will date them as I add them to this post body. These are all reported in no particular order, more so how my brain decided to work.

Ahead of the release of AS3 tonight, it's time we had another Dirty Deets megathread. Every season we get a fresh wave of "What is this?" and "Can someone explain the lore?" posts, followed by seventeen conflicting answers, three side quests, and somehow an argument that has absolutely nothing to do with the original question. While some users suggest searching the sub, what starts as a simple search often ends with seventeen open tabs and even more questions than when you started.

You ask, I am here to provide. Included in this post you'll find common acronyms, sub jokes, some back history on certain drama, and other Dirty Deet threads. Think of it as the unofficial study guide. I am human and susceptible to mistakes in my reporting. If you see any, please let me know and I can edit the thread. If you have information you think belongs here, let me know and I can add it.

Now, this sub likes to argue. Probably true of most of reddit honestly. But, try not to be a moist walnut and ruin it. At least have some human decency while interacting with others instead of threatening, doxxing, or losing your minds over reddit drama, you pinecones.

Pull up a chair, grab a snack, and raise your hand if you have questions. History class has started. No bathroom breaks, you don’t want to miss anything!

DISCLAIMER: As with every Dirty Deets thread, keep in mind these are rumors. Rumors have the chance to be true and false, or in-between. Do not shoot the messenger, I'm just here to report. These rumors come from retired vets, PT, social media tea, insiders, and so on.

COMMON ACRONYMS/NAMES/PHRASES

TPTB: The Powers That Be
MTT: Making The Team (DCCs original show)
DCC: Dallas Cowboys Cheerleader
TCC: Training Camp Candidate
TC: Training Camp
AS: America’s Sweethearts (Netflix show)
CMT: Country Music Network (original network that MTT aired)
K & J: Kelli and Judy
KF: Kelli Finglass
JT: Judy Trammell
TK: Tina Kalina (she is also a resident reddit crazy, look out for anything “glass” in the username, she has multiple profiles)
VK: Victoria Kalina
AK: Anna-Kate
KD: KayDianna
MRS: Melissa Rycroft Strickland (DCC Showmanship coach for all of 2 seconds)
Wilbur: Reese’s husband, Will Allman
Reesus: Reece
AYTOL: Reddit username for an insider to the DCC organization. Also known as u/dcc_updates on Instagram
Primetimer: a TV show forum where an active forum for DCC still operates, though most have moved to Reddit now.
USO Tour or simply “Tour”: (United Service Organizations), DCC will go on tour to perform, long standing thing in the organization
HBIC: Head Bitch In Charge

OTHER DIRTY DEET THREADS

VK/TK Dirty Deets Thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/DCCMakingtheTeam/comments/1lhnwpq/the_dirty_deets_on_vktk_and_more/

KD Dirty Deets Thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/DCCMakingtheTeam/comments/1k9qr3k/the_dirty_deets_on_kd_and_more/

LEGACY RELATIONS

Amber Gosdin (cheered 1995-1996 & 2003-2004): Billie Gosdin (cheered 1979-1980)
Meredith Oden (TCC 2005, cheered 2007-2011): Mom Kim Oden (cheered 1982-1984)
Cassie Trammell (cheered 2008-2013): Judy Trammell (cheered 1980-1984)
Madeline Salter (TCC 2019, cheered2021-2025): Shannon Salter (cheered 1987-1989)
Victoria Kalina (TCC 2018, cheered 2019-2020, 2022-2023): Tina Kalina (cheered 1984, 1988-1989)
Dayton Davison (finalist 2017, TCC 2018 & 2024): Shelley Bramhall (cheered 1989-1990, 1994-1996)
Maegan Morrison (finalist season 6 MTT): Melissa Sullivan (cheered 1995-1996)
Nadia Marcella (auditioned season 7 MTT): Natasha McCarley (cheered 1985-1986)
Cami Branson (auditioned 2014): Candy Causey (1983-1984)
Bianca (auditioned 2017, not mentioned by name on TV): Stacy Malmay (1991-1993)

PAST DRAMA

This is where things get messy. Many of these have been talked about repeatedly. Some with conflicting information, some not. I am recording these here to the best of my knowledge. But, as always, comment corrections or additions and I can review them. And if you haven’t watched MTT, only having AS for your source of information, you are missing a lot of context. I highly encourage you to go watch MTT.

DCC Vets Mass Exodus

In the summer of 1989, 14 vets walked off the team when changes to the team went against their comfort zones and the foundations in which they believed DCC to be built upon. Rumors began circulating that Jerry Jones wanted to make drastic, controversial changes to the squad. Skimpier uniforms, hard to imagine, but they were being pushed to the absolute limits on short and tight. New corporate promotions involved beer promotions and other less than savory business dealings for a team dubbed “America’s Sweethearts”. The fraternization rule was going to be thrown out the window in favor of more interaction with the team and DCC to the point of participating in relationships to elevate the profile of certain players. Due to these, and more, 14 vets walked off the team and put the DCC in a mass panic with no cheerleaders to carry the team.

Early MTT seasons “mean girls”

The original mean girls (per MTT era) were the Brooke Sorenson and Michelle Keys clique. There was a core group vs another core group, typical high-school drama. Insert the word “mean girls” and you can assume how they acted, as any other societal mean girl out there. Lots of picking on rookies, shutting girls out of activities, picking apart appearances, you name it.

Meredith Oden:

"No Cheating When Eating, you want to be SKINNY" was a sign shown during her audition season on MTT. Rumor is production planted that sign there. It’s still a toss up if production put it there since many have speculated it could be a legit thing based on Meredith’s attitude, demeanor, and attitudes towards weight during this era.

Cassie Trammell:

Cassie has quite a few things related to her. As Judy Trammell’s daughter, the moment she stepped foot on the audition floor. Granted, the era she auditioned in the dancers hadn’t hit the talent level that was starting to appear in season 5 and 6 of MTT, she was still dubbed as a noodle arm, nepo baby, lack of talent dancer.

Cassie’s USO drama. These rumors have been floating around for years. The general story goes that Cassie got drunk, she was late for an appearance, etc. And then the biggest one, she snuck out of her hotel room after curfew, slept with a soldier, and was caught by someone. The military was supposedly not thrilled with the situation and the DCC were not invited back. DCC still does USO events within the United States, but they no longer travel like they used to. There used to be a massive Christmas USO tour where Show Group traveled through multiple countries. That's why they were always told to have their passports ready. One of those international trips is also where Cassie injured her knee. Given how much military audiences seem to love the DCC, many people have questioned why those larger tours disappeared and this is assumed why.

Another Cassie lore, she is the reason Olivia S was cut. Cassie was complaining that rookies were getting more shoot time during a calendar trip. Olivia said something to Cassie about her complaints, which in turn Cassie got Olivia S labeled as toxic, and then she was cut the following auditions.

This particular one I giggle at because it sounds so silly but thought I’d share it anyways. Judy paid producers and cowboys organization to get Cassie on the team/keep Cassie on the team. I mean, could be, could be.

Whitney Isleib & Rachel Whyatt Black/Brown face

Whitney Isleib decided she would be “funny” and dress up as Lil’ Wayne for Halloween. Did the organization cut her? Not a chance. Did they defend her and protect her? Absolutely. And she managed to get point position too. Same with Rachel Wyatt. She decided to pull the same move and dress up as Bruno Mars for Halloween. Both women very obviously colored their skin in an attempt to “be accurate” but we all know that translates to “racist assholes”.

Ally Traylor (affectionately called “Traylor-trash):

Ally was one of the Vets, along with Cassie, that called TCC Taylor out in the middle of practice, scolded her, and made her cry. She has been known as mean girl and butt-kisser.

Ally had some issue with Kaitlyn LeGrande, putting more pressure on her from said bullying of sorts, and it increased her lack of commitment to the team, on top of what was already going on at home. It was known that Ally Traylor was a teacher’s pet bully. She supposedly made it difficult for TCCs and would put them down while they were trying to learn everything. Basically the "I earned my vet status, you need to respect me, I can get you kicked off because I'm an important vet."

Carla Ann:

Carla Ann was a TCC who was cut because her boyfriend posted nudes of her as a form of revenge porn. K & J had an office visit with her on camera and blamed her for the issue, not the boyfriend. They said she made bad choices and they can’t afford to have someone like her on the team. It was rumored that she was always planned to be cut but they brought her on, knowing her photos were posted, but they used her for a drama storyline in the season. Other TCCs who were cut for their photos were Ika Irene and Karissa Lynae. Karrissa was given a “second chance” but cut for her dancing later, though it’s speculated they kept her for another source of drama in an episode and had always planned to cut her.

DCCs who had similar issues or their personal photos on their phone were hacked but were not cut were Tobie Percival, Olivia Renee, Holly A, and Heather O.

Voyeurism Lawsuit & Charlotte Jones Up-skirt Photos:

This article summarizes it better than I could…

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/33231841/dallas-cowboys-paid-24-million-settle-cheerleaders-voyeurism-allegations

“THE DALLAS COWBOYS paid a confidential settlement of $2.4 million after four members of their iconic cheerleading squad accused a senior team executive of voyeurism in their locker room as they undressed during a 2015 event at AT&T Stadium, according to documents obtained by ESPN and people with knowledge of the situation.”

“Dalrymple also was accused by a lifelong Cowboys fan of taking "upskirt" photos of Charlotte Jones Anderson, a team senior vice president and the daughter of team owner Jerry Jones, in the Cowboys' war room during the 2015 NFL draft, according to documents obtained by ESPN and interviews. The fan signed an affidavit that he was watching a livestream of the war room on the team's website when he said he saw the alleged incident.”

Erica Wilkins Lawsuit

This article summarizes it better than I could…

https://nypost.com/2018/06/17/dallas-cowboys-cheerleader-reveals-why-shes-suing-the-team/

VK/TK Controversy

(See VK/TK Dirty Deets Thread above)

Bahamas-gate

(See KD Dirty Deets Thread above)

Holly/Jenna

During the MTT days, season 12, Holly and Jenna were partying. Holly being underage made the situation complicated as Jenna was sneaking Holly into clubs. Both were rumored to have been involved with players and chatter around the players locker-room is what alerted K & J. Jenna was demoted from her leadership position and point position (given to Kashara following this), Holly was put on notice and then later resigned (read encouraged to leave). Jenna did not receive her point position back and Kashara remained in point position the rest of her tenure.

Kalyssa, Alexandra, and Milan Season 12

Kelli remarks “attrition” during season 13 MTT, beginning talking heads, about how the squad faced issues. She mentions she regrets having cut Brennan because of these issues. This was in relation to Kalyssa and Alexandra specifically. Alexandra left due to issues at home and missing family, rumor mill also states it is due to Jenna being problematic and power trippy. Kalyssa left before completing her season to take on a modeling career where she joined the adult modeling world and famously started posting scantily clad lingerie photography. Milan was rumored to have left mid-season to study abroad.

06/15/26: Added info, Shelly B and Melissa confirmed Kalyssa was cut, she did not leave.

Savannah & Tara mean girls “burn book”

According to Primetimer, Savannah and Tara supposedly went through a squad photo and marked which teammates they thought should be cut. Another cheerleader saw the photo, word got back to some of the girls who had been marked, and all hell broke loose. Savannah spent a lot of time apologizing and trying to repair the damage, while Tara did not. It was pretty catty, but the details are mixed on how bad that got.

TCC Tessa David-Burns survives life threatening stroke

This article summarizes it better than I could…

https://people.com/health/former-colts-cheerleader-tessa-david-burns-on-overcoming-a-massive-stroke-at-28/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nvvED_CIDoE

K & J not going to all practices

According to former cheerleaders, Kelli and Judy were not at every rehearsal back in the day. They would typically come in for evaluations, which conveniently tended to coincide with CMT filming nights when everyone was expected to be camera-ready. On non-filming nights, the girls could dress much more casually, and rehearsals were generally run by assistant choreographers and/or group leaders. Kelli and Judy didn't necessarily need to watch every step of the learning process; they wanted to see the finished product a few days later and determine who was ready to perform and who was still struggling. Coincidentally, this is rumored to be why Kaitlin LeGrande may have been out of uniform the day she was cut, because she was confused.

Girls in trouble with the law

Whitney Robertson attacked her ex-boyfriend

https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/miami-dolphins-cheerleader-attacked-ex-boyfriend-during-burglary-police/79418/

Alexandra Benvenuto had a speeding history and was ticketed. No news on any arrests but allegedly she was in trouble again years later for wreckers driving.

Kaitlin LeGrande, she was arrested most recently in 2024 for endangering her children, unauthorized vehicle use, and resisting arrest.

(2024 mugshot): https://tarranttx.mugshots.zone/legrand-kaitlin-ann-mugshot-09-04-2024/#google_vignette

https://www.tiktok.com/@thedcchistorian/video/7526023322853788942

https://www.reddit.com/r/DCCMakingtheTeam/comments/12tourd/kaitlin_legrand/

Kaitlyn LeGrande:

Kaitlyn was cut for “maturity” reasons, and what she had going on at home. She missed a practice and showed up late, had an office visit where she appeared to be under the influence of something, and gave a weird explanation as to what happened. One of the following practices she showed up out of uniform, was called into the office, and released from training camp. Rumor around that time was that she was having immense pressure put on her at home. And then her boyfriend at the time was dealing with meth and she was getting involved in drugs to cope.

MRS

Melissa Rycroft went on The Bachelor after breaking up with her current husband to get back at him. Her tenure ended with DCC in 2008 and her vet status was used to get her on the Bachelor in 2008/2009, producers thought the tie in would up her status and the shows status.

She had a brief falling out with K and J over her book release in 2012 where she dissed them in the book and the organization, small conflict. CMT produced the reality show with MRS and her husband to save face and reintroduce her to CMT audiences to bring her on as mentor in 2014 (season 9). She was not on chummy terms with K and J because of the book conflict, they were forced to play nice, being paid to play nice helps as well. Later CMT held a poll if they should keep MRS on DCC as mentor and the audience voted no, she was removed.

Her more recent arrest articles for DUI…

https://www.dallasnews.com/arts-entertainment/2025/10/06/melissa-rycroft-strickland-former-dallas-cowboys-cheerleader-bachelor-alum-arrested/

https://people.com/the-bachelor-star-melissa-rycroft-speaks-out-after-dui-arrest-11824006

Ashley Hancock cut (2019 ex-Mavs)

2 varying theories as to why she was cut. The first being she had a sugar daddy, which isn’t unheard of or out of pocket for the Dallas area. The other theory being she failed her written test twice.

Alora Rose

Alora-Rose did not leave New York to pursue DCC as portrayed on the show. Instead, she was essentially shunned from the New York dance scene and turned to DCC as a last resort. When she attempted to return to the Rockettes she was shut out again. The core of the rumor is not that she chose DCC over New York, but that New York was already done with her.

Loni Lindsay

Loni Lindsay was only used for looks and was pulled off kick line if they could help it. She struck a chord with her more “mature” look and was kept for that per Charlottes request.

Show production for MTT

There are a handful of whispers around about varying production members. Claims of harassment, all the way to girls having relationships with film crews/people from CMT show.

You have to pay a fee or sign some contract to keep your storyline off the show and only on camera if necessary, passing scenes on someone else's storyline.

Salon’s working with DCC

Reiner (hair guy in earlier seasons) quit because he was tired of Kellys outdated input and didn't like that she disrespected his creative freedom he needed to create good looks. He was often micromanaged in his out expertise and grew tired of being treated like a child.

Courtney Cook

Allegedly Judy gave Courney Cassie’s ADHD meds (Adderall) for her to lose weight. This was supposedly what triggered her mental health to get worse, and she had to leave the team and go home.

Vivian and her poem

In MTT we see Vivian read her very…interesting…poem. She was on the brink of a breakdown and was talking to someone in production about writing out her feelings. Production egged her on to share it with K & J, saying that they would appreciate to hear her thoughts because it would show her commitment to being on the team. And she’s cut the following episode.

Sintia Jimmy

https://dallascowboyscheerleaders.fandom.com/wiki/Sintia_Jimmy

Sintia was dismissed from training camp following a criminal charge that occurred during TC. The show largely edited her out of the footage, though she can still be spotted with the other rookies in some of the early training camp scenes. It was essentially treated as though she had never been there on the show

Kelli dressing room drama

Kelli is reportedly a less than kind shopper. She makes demands, doesn’t use her manners, and blames other people for her own issues. One day I am sure this story will be deleted so I will have a screenshot in the comment section for posterity.

https://www.reddit.com/r/DCCMakingtheTeam/s/fL0XS27UJc

Lacey & Kinley Minchew

These pageant sisters were on season 4, both made it to TC but later dropped out due to prior commitments in their pageant systems. Supposedly they were brought on as a storyline, but this was not told to K & J.

Hannah/Brennan cuts & Ozark Girls

The bubble cuts for Hannah and Brennan have always been controversial. Especially since they both were speaking out against issues with the team and concerns with COVID, yet the girls that road tripped to Ozark weren’t punished. A double standard was brought up and complaints from Hannah and Brennan. Surprise, they were cut. The Ozark girls were Caroline, Tess, (edit) Daphne, & Kat. The Ozark girls thought they could travel by car and that the rule only applied to airplane travel.

06/15/26: Pending confirmation of which girls were involved due to conflicting groups of names on Primetimer. Will update with further confirmation. It is also stated (oh the irony) that they went out to bars drinking and getting wasted. "Loophole" for the plane travel/car travel, but then all out the window with bar hopping.

I know we all know there are a lot of vet retirees coming up and the confirmations will trickle in slowly. But this being the first was shocking but I guess expected.

Didn't see this coming, girl. Poor Sheridan retired before even making the team, quickest tenure ever, girl.