u/subtle_as_a_hammer

I DNF's PBP 2x. Should I even try again next year?

2019 - everything hurt (basically inexperience)

2023 - Sprained my ankle 1 month prior to pbp so I did not have enough training

Now PBP is coming up again and to be honest, I'm not even sure if I should go.

I'd truly enjoyed the fanfare and riding through France. But the idea of possibly not finishing a third time feels like a punch in the gut.

How many times did you DNF PBP?

reddit.com
u/subtle_as_a_hammer — 12 days ago

Question to STs: How much do you interfere when people are pushing info due to misunderstanding their role or info?

How much should an ST interfere when the players clearly misunderstood the role and info esp. when the game is clearly being driven by the misunderstanding?

E.g. I saw a game where people threw sus at the Undertaker because the undertaker did not provide info after a demon kill (town did not execute that day.) Players are new so they thought executions and demon kills are the same.

The ST did not interfere and let the undertaker get executed.

Personally I think the ST should have at least cleared the diff bet. executions and demon kills.

reddit.com
u/subtle_as_a_hammer — 1 month ago

Meta: how do you handle your "tell" when you play with your usual group?

I am told I tend to play a certain way when I am evil vs good. Or I have a "tell".

How to fix that? I found others just act suspiciously all the time but I don't think I can pull that off.

I find it easier to play with others I don't know because my group basically almost knows my alignment bases on my "tell".

reddit.com
u/subtle_as_a_hammer — 2 months ago