Best pizza in or near Middletown
We moved here 3 years ago and still haven’t found our nearby go-to. We love Patsy’s and Razza, but also love a great crisp NY slice. We’ve tried the following, and while some have had their merits, none has called us back:
Valentinos in Belford
Sally Boy’s in Red Bank (the best of these but a bit too far)
Corbo and Sons in Holmdel
Pomodoro Rosso in Atlantic Highlands
Panko in Middletown
Rosie’s in Middletown
Zoni’s in Middletown
Toscanella in Middletown
Would love to get some new recommendations to try!