
Moved my domain from .ai to .com two months in.
I registered my company's .ai domain on June 5, it was the only available at the time. Last week I made the move to .com. I've done this before at a previous company, .io to .com two years in, and it wrecked our search traffic for months. So this time I pulled every number first.
Google Search Console for the .ai, June 12 to Aug 11, basically the entire life of the domain:
- 48 clicks
- 5,470 impressions
- Average position 30.8
- Not 48 thousand.
Three things I found that I hadn't expected.
1. The impression spike was fake. Last week of July my impressions went from 40/day to 400/day for eight days, then collapsed. Clicks didn't move at all. I pulled the indexing report and put it on the same axis: Google had indexed 27 new pages on July 24. Two days later the spike started. It was Google testing new pages at deep positions, getting no clicks, and withdrawing. If I'd used that week as my baseline I'd have "lost 70% of my traffic" post-migration and it would've meant nothing.
2. Almost all my traffic was my own brand name. 28 of 48 clicks came from the homepage, and my top queries were the company name "brandscreen" and "brand screen" at positions 2.2 and 2.9. Which means I had essentially zero non-brand organic to lose. The thing everyone warns you about with migrations didn't apply to me, and probably doesn't apply to most people asking about it.
3. Google and Bing are completely different environments. Bing sat flat at 20-40 impressions/day through Google's entire spike. And when I checked indexed pages: Google 335, Bing 13. None of the 13 were blog posts. But Copilot cited us 487 times over the same period, off that thirteen-page index. So an AI product was quoting us constantly while nobody clicked through from the search engine behind it.
What's happened since (7 days):
Redirects went live Aug 7, all 308s, path-preserving, single hop. Google started serving the .com on Aug 10: 161 impressions day one, 685 day two. Brand query "brandscreen" is already position 1 on the new domain. My domain-checker tool page dropped from position 39 to 90, which based on the July pattern I read as Google re-testing a new URL rather than a penalty. Time will tell.
The thing I actually can't find an answer to: all 487 of those Copilot citations point at .ai URLs. What ChatGPT, Copilot, and Perplexity do with redirects isn't documented anywhere I could find. I took a baseline of 8 prompts across 4 engines before switching and I'm re-running it weekly. I should have more information soon, since time is really the main driver here.
Happy to share the raw exports or answer anything. Also curious if anyone's measured the AI citation side of a migration, because I came up empty.