r/AllStarBrawl

No updates since 2024. Like what happend

Is it time that the community takes this game into our own hands and create a Project NASB or NASB+ fan mod. New characters, stages, bug fixes, roster balancing etc? I think Project Plus rendition of this game would be extremely possible and more accessible to everyone. Just my opinion.

Body text,

Servers still up for the 1st game??? i remember playing this like 2 years ago and nothing working properly

Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 3 is something we really need, but there are a few major things it has to get right.

First, the price. One of the biggest issues with the first game was that it felt way too expensive for the amount of content it had. I picked up nasb1 for around $15 on sale, and honestly, that felt fair. I’ve thought about getting All-Star Brawl 2, but the price is still a big reason I haven’t. At $60, it’s just not worth it when you can get something like Smash instead.

If they want more people to actually try the game, it should be priced lower, like $20–$30. That makes it feel like a solid alternative rather than a risky purchase. More players trying it means a bigger community, which helps the game long-term anyway.

Next is the roster. This is a huge problem for me. The main reason I haven’t bought All-Star Brawl 2 is because so many characters I played are gone. I used CatDog, Leonardo, and Oblina, and all three were cut. That means I’d have to completely relearn the game with new mains, which is a tough sell.

Cuts are understandable sometimes, but they need to prioritize bringing back fan-favorite characters. CatDog and all the Ninja Turtles should absolutely return. Oblina too, though I might be a bit biased there. Characters like Shredder would also be a great addition, instead of Rocksteady( I hate him)

They should also expand the roster with more iconic characters. Timmy Turner is an obvious one. Master Splinter would be great. Clyde from The Loud House could work too. And adding more Jimmy Neutron characters would help round things out. The roster should feel like a true celebration of Nickelodeon, not a random mix. Or thay can pull an everyone is here

As for content, the story mode needs improvement. All-Star Brawl 2 had a decent foundation, but it needs to be expanded and polished. Adding more modes would also go a long way. Something like target practice or other side challenges would help make the game feel more complete.

A Subspace Emissary-style mode would be amazing, with a full crossover story and cutscenes. Realistically, that might be too expensive given the budget, but even a scaled-down version with stylized visuals and some more voice acting would be a huge step up.

Overall, the game doesn’t need to compete directly with bigger titles. It just needs to lean into what makes it unique: a fun, chaotic Nickelodeon crossover with strong character representation and solid content. If they can get that right, it could really stand out.

(First of all, I'm not yelling, I use caps because they're pretty)

MANY PEOPLE ARE UPSET BECAUSE THE 4 TEENAGE MUTANT NINJA TURTLES AREN'T TOGETHER IN THE SAME GAME, INSTEAD WE HAD 2 TURTLES PER GAME, DESPITE THEIR COMPLAINS ARE UNDERTANDABLE AND OBJECTIVELY AREN'T WRONG, PERSONALLY I DON'T MIND NOT HAVING ALL THE 4 TOGETHER, THE 4 TURTLES HAVE BEEN TOGETHER IN EVERY GAME THEY WERE, THIS WAS THE FIRST TIME (AT LEAST FROM WHAT I KNOW) THEY WEREN'T, WHICH IT IS GOOD AT CERTAIN POINT, BECAUSE IT GIVES US MORE VARIETY OF CHARACTERS FROM NICKELODEON, IF THE 4 TURTLES WERE TOGETHER FROM THE FIRST GAME, OTHER CHARACTERS WOULDN'T HAVE BEEN INTRODUCED INTO THE GAME, AND BESIDES, DOING THE SAME THING OVER AND OVER IS BORING AND PREDICTABLE.

SO THAT'S MY OPINION, IF YOU WANT TO THROW ME STICKS & STONES, GO AHEAD

This is a part 2 to a roster I posted last month, so see that for context.
In my NASB3 concept assists work similar to MvC1 or Fraymakers, where they are a separate roster from the playable fighters and are selected before a match.
(there isn't a picture this time I didn't feel like making one)

The base assist line-up includes:
-Gary
-Larry the Lobster
-The Flying Dutchman
-Grandpat Star
-Nermal
-Carl Wheezer
-Ember
-Pigeon Man
-Robosnail
-Waffle Woman
-The Gromble
-Log
-The Greasers
-Donnie Thornberry
-Skrawl
-Rock
-Pig
-Mr. Crocker
-Poof
-Taz
-Frida
-Heffer
-XJ-9
-Misty
-Karai (2012)
-Mondo Gecko (Tales)
-Baron Draxum
-April (87)
-Clyde McBride
-Appa
-Katara
-Amon

And the DLC adds:
-Odie
-Otto Rocket
-Baxter Stockman (03)
-Kyle the Wizard