Surly Big Easy VS Yuba Spicy Curry VS Xtracycle Swoop ASM
Researching the family's first e-cargo as a means for getting the kids to school and getting out for adventures. I am 5'8 175lbs and the kids are almost 4 and 6, 35lbs and 55lbs. Oldest is also dang tall! I ride a Kona Dr. Dew and they're on Woom's 2 and 3 for reference. Pretty set on a long tail as I feel like I'll have the most control. Location is Spokane WA.
The Surly Big Easy is what I want! I love it, the color, wheel size, geo etc. Reminds me of my Kona. Hangups w/ that one are the deck height and it's higher center of gravity, the higher step over (dropper post helps), and the foot placement of both kids, not just one. It seems like this was perhaps built as cargo first and kid 2nd? Nonetheless a cool bike. One I could see benefiting the family on bike adventures the most, giving our youngest breaks on the back or hauling gear.
The Yuba, looking at V4(+) or the V3 A/T. These seem to take some good parts of the Surly and drop the load down some with the 20" rear wheel alleviating those concerns. There is also a wider set of accessories for kids, though stock is sparse currently. Hangups with Yuba are many the longer I research.
- How long will they be in the US?
- My dealer had them on the website, but nobody there had even heard of them.
- Many have stated poor customer service.
- How much of a pain is it to take out the battery on the V4?
- Not the biggest fan of any of the colors or looks, it's alright I guess..
- Some mentioned chain rub on the V3, does that happen on V4?
Still, this might suit our needs perfectly blending school drop offs and some off pavement exploring. A/T seems cool and class 3 is definite plus with that, just not sure if it's worth going for an older model. Yuba touts enhanced laterall frame stiffness as an upgrade from gen 3 to 4. Anybody ridden both?
Then there's the Xtracycle Swoop ASM. I found them by searching "pinion belt drive e cargo" having bought from Priority about 5 years back I thought they might have something. Initially I was off put by the 24"/20" combo and Shimano Steps motor but I kept coming back to it. It's built with kids in mind first. It comes with a bunch of accessories. It has UDH! It seems fairly priced, and class 3! Hangups are the auto shift feature and having to turn that off everytime, the smaller wheels and yeah, compared to the Surly and even the Yuba it's not great to look at but bonus points for Steel. Also no dealer network. There is no doubt this would be the easiest to get the kids on and off, but our off pavement rides would be fewer with this for sure.
That's where I'm at. There are none around to test ride. One dealer can get the Surly or the Yuba, another dealer can order from Tern, but that's about it. Any input is appreciated, especially from a parents point of view. What else did I miss? Thanks!