r/CrumblCookies

…tastes AMAZING… allegedly

Just keep the recipe the same, it’s a good recipe that doesn’t need to be changed

she post about crumbl

OMG this is one of the best Crumbl cookies I’ve ever tasted. I LOVE oatmeal in cookies so I was down big time for this cookie. I used my points but now I wish I had splurged and gotten a 4 pack 😩 I have nothing negative to say about it - 10/10 mami 🔥

Never used mine because I didn’t care for any of the choices. Thought someone else could use it so it doesn’t go to waste. Enjoy!

*Spoilers are never 100% guaranteed so check back weekly for any changes. This is what I currently know right now. A lot of changes are happening so read the notes on the bottom of the spoiler page. Thank you.

Title should say (As of 5/19/26)

How y’all feel about this?

With the new changes, no employees, managers etc can see the spoilers for weeks ahead which kind of sucks. Before yesterday, I was still able to see descriptions & ingredients for the upcoming lineup for the next two weeks - that is not case no more.

On Sunday, before they removed the ingredients lists, I was able to see the week of June 1-6 lineup and it’s giving breakfast week.
For that week we have:

🥣Cereal Milk Tres Leches - the ingredients for this had Froot Loops instead of Fruity Pebbles interesting.

🫐Blueberry Pancake cookie

🍞French Toast Cookie

🍓Frosted Strawberry Pop Tart cookie

🍩Pink Doughnut cookie

🍫Hazelnut Sea Salt cookie

Classic Menu: S’mores Cookie, Brownie Batter, Pink Sugar and Chocolate Chip cookie.
Thins: Chocolate Chip Thins (available all week)

‼️ This is all subject to change. Corporate is still redeveloping the menu‼️

Disclaimer - I am an employee and make my own cookies. Reviews are based on how we test and sell them.

Lemon cake 🍋 4/10 - as much as I love the lemon curd and lemon frosting, the cakes fall short for the millionth time that crumbl sells a layered cake. Even when brushed with milk, they are still dry and fall apart like sand. They have no structure or density to them and they would benefit from altering the recipe to be more like the dense heart cakes. The lemon flavor is barely noticeable in the cake layers and the frosting and curd is definitely doing the heavy lifting. And why are we still using fresh lemon slices on top? Candy them or use a lemon candy for the love of god.

Chips Ahoy 🍪 6/10 - I've never really liked this one, but it's not bad either. Just very.. meh. The base is the best part because it's a chocolate chip cookie rolled in chips ahoy crumbs. The frosting is a simple white drop frosting colored blue, so it doesn’t really add much to the ‘blue monster’ theme other than the color. Usually, when I think of blue monster dessert, I think of ice cream. Vanilla ice cream colored blue, Oreos and chips ahoys. Where’s the Oreo?! It’s a pretty cookie, but it doesn’t execute well in the flavor category.

Molten lava 🌋 8.5/10 - I remember the first time I had this cookie, it was an instant favorite because it’s so rich and decadent. This is one of the few cookies I enjoy warm because the chocolate fudge in the middle is ooey gooey, just like a molten lava cake. I wish there was a way to make the powdered sugar taste stronger, because trying to put a layer of powdered sugar on top of a warm cookie is nearly impossible. Besides that, the cookie is super soft, but packed full of cocoa. I need a glass of milk!

Caramelita 🍮 9.8/10 - well good golly, I was not expecting to like this one nearly as much as I do! It’s definitely not visually appealing, and kind of looks like a bunch of scabs.. but the flavors and textures are strong. The base is an oatmeal pie base, baked twice. There’s milk chocolate chips and caramel in the middle, then a layer of oatmeal streusel on top, which is just the base cookie dough, but only baked once. I am sad they took the pecans out of it, because I love pecans and they would have provided a nice crunch. But the richness of the caramel, sweetness of the milk chocolate and savory oatmeal comes together wonderfully. It’s also super soft and not crunchy at all, so I’m a huge huge huuuuge fan of this cookie!

I added more caramel to mine but also wanted to show what it looks like normally.

Cat tax 🐱 - ol mister Milo and Peanut wish you a relaxing, yet adventure filled week this week