r/Hannibal

Criticism of a depraved Harpist called «Horudja». The writer says this filthy man's voice and performance are so horrible to the point Sekhmet and Horus wanted to kill him. 2nd century CE. [2002x3000]
▲ 1.6k r/Hannibal+3 crossposts

Criticism of a depraved Harpist called «Horudja». The writer says this filthy man's voice and performance are so horrible to the point Sekhmet and Horus wanted to kill him. 2nd century CE. [2002x3000]

>It is sadness and suffering for the soul to hear the voice of this dreadful man when he sings. He is truly a deplorable singer, and he only sings well-known songs.

>He goes to the temple when he should not, and makes the god hear what they hate.

>How does he present himself at a festival? Like the best in his art. He sits down, looking very important, like a real singer, and he lifts the harp to sing, thinking in his mind, he is a virtuoso.

>No one realises that he is a huge fool because his stupidity overwhelms the public. He sings in a shrill voice,  even when his mouth proclaims his own glory. Whoever sees him singing is afflicted for the day.

>There is no need for many words, because he has all the faults. Who taught him to play the harp?  From whom did he learn to sing? His interpretation is jerky because his usual task is digging, his skill is watering. His fingers are like gnarled wood, they are not made for a harp.

>His voice makes more noise than a heavy shovel. He has innumerable faults,more than in the songs of Busiris.

>Isheru's mistress became angry with him - the great Sekhmet. He is overcome by her plague,  he is overpowered by her anger.  So he will never again carry his harp before the mistress of Egypt.

>In his old age he is full of horror, he is oppressed by filth. Horus is very angry with him; he is going to get killed by the son of Isis.

>He was given the name Horudja  even though "Arsehole" is the name that suits him.

>A great song for the temple of Mut, an adoration for the mistress of Egypt,  it is a true masterpiece whose meaning he manages to pervert.

>We would have said: "He acts out of ignorance", and no reproach would reach him for that. But he has only silence from doctrine, he draws no benefit from the words.

>In fact, he has learned but he knows nothing, he has received teaching but does not retain it. Like a mute person who understands but cannot answer correctly.

>Like a fool who takes up a book and remains dumb in front of all the texts. He has not known any song except one since his birth : "I'm hungry! Give me a drink! • What is there to eat?" What about the one who cooks • in front of him, if he sees meat?

>He is quicker than a fly to blood, faster than a vulture which has seen carrion.

>He will be able to spend four days awake  looking for some food that is hidden. If someone shouts to him: "Meat!" in a loathsome place, he is present, with harp in front, but he does not . . . a man who is dirtier than his neighbour.

>And whoever displays bread and meat to him, he will go to his house without being invited. And he will say to the venues: I cannot sing if I am hungry.

>I cannot raise my harp to play unless I have had my fill of wine. Order it! And he drinks wine for two, eats meat for three: food for five in all.

> But the harp weighs down on him, like an uncomfortable burden. So that every person must be made to say, three times each: "Sing!"

>If he starts to raise his harp when drunk, then all of his vices comes to light.

>He turns the harp with his hand, he sings again 'The faults of women'. When he begins to raise the tune, his mouth sings his glory. But what he sings does not match his playing; his voice and harp are discordant.

>His poor performance shows his disregard of the music. The gentleness of good manners, he has not even begun to understand it.

>He cannot be accepted anywhere because of the number of his faults. If he is full, he puts away the harp; if he is replete, he leaves.


>I would mention the misdeeds he committed, but they are more numerous than those of Seth. He went in a funeral procession to the West last year, from Psonis to Akhmim.

>He acted as a sacrificer,  but I cannot say what he did there: "It's not even worth talking about," as they say to make their meaning clear. He declared the animals good for sacrifice, even those protected by the god . . .

>He disregarded the seal that sanctified the animals . . . and he ignored even the supervising priest. And then, whatever was brought to him on the block, he stabbed . . . with a knife. And he was the first to eat the meat . . . without knowing how to cook it.

u/Appropriate-Weird492 — 2 days ago
▲ 2.2k r/Hannibal+1 crossposts

Who do you think played a role so perfectly that you literally cannot imagine anyone else playing it? For me, it has to be Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter

u/Vzxmarr — 3 days ago

Ayuda jeje

Estoy haciendo digamos un fanfic adaptando hannibal rising para la continuidad de la serie NBC de hannibal pero estoy confundido y algo perdido ya que aunque tengo aquí conmigo la novela hannibal rising como apoyo, solo me sirve prácticamente como una fuente de algunos datos del lore y para inspirar me en los sucesos, pero los eventos de esta historia en la serie fueron diferentes y muchas cosas en general de la serie fueron diferentes a lo que ocurrió en esta novela, una de ellas es que le pasó realmente a los padres de hannibal, en la novela tengo entendido que murieron por un ataque de bombardeo de la segunda guerra mundial, sin embargo como dije la serie difere de esto y es algo ambigua con los detalles, por lo que solicito sugerencias de como adaptar la muerte de los padres de hannibal sin el contexto de la segunda guerra mundial y el bombardeo

reddit.com
u/Usual_Orchid_8210 — 4 days ago

Hannibal book cover question

This is a 2019 edition of the paperback and I cannot find any information at all about what the cover art is - except a small line at the bottom of the back cover “cover photography of winged figure by Leno”. Who on earth is Leno? I can’t seem to find out. Previous cover arts have been very apparent in their references to the series so this one is odd to me.

u/boomch1ckenboom — 5 days ago

Hannibal (2001): The cut “cutting” shot?

I used to have an old downloaded copy of Hannibal (2001) that I watched many, MANY times during my teenage years and early twenties. Eventually I bought the Blu-ray and ended up losing the old copy to a broken external hard drive.

But when I watched the Blu-ray, I noticed something extremely odd and I was hoping someone might know something about it.

I remember the Paul Krendler brain dinner scene extremely well and clearly, because (and don’t judge me) there was a particular shot of Hannibal that I always found really satisfying, using the blade in his right hand to slice a piece of Krendler’s prefrontal lobe off BEFORE Starling asks for wine and then the closeup shot of him dropping the piece of brain into the pan. Now I am aware that he cuts open the “sac” which contains the brain (the meninges) before peeling it back, but this isn’t what I’m talking about. In the Blu-ray cut I have (and in all of the YouTube videos of this scene) it just cuts from Starling saying “I would really like some wine!” to the brain piece being dropped into the pan. No shot of him actually slicing the piece off.

I haven’t imagined it, it isn’t a false memory. I must have watched the film using the same .mkv file for a good 10 years and in that space of time I probably watched it 15 times. I really like Anthony Hopkins and I think he is superb as Lecter. But the specific fact that I find the shot where he physically slices off the piece so satisfying (and visually impressive from a practical and digital effects perspective) cements the fact I haven’t misremembered it. I suspect it was cut in more recent Blu-ray copies of the film due to classification and the particular shot being deemed extravagantly graphic. But I cannot find a single source to support this. Can anyone shine a light onto this mystery for me please?

TLDR; does anyone else remember the shot of Hannibal physically slicing off the piece of Krendler’s frontal lobe prior to Starling exclaiming that she’d like a glass of wine and then dropping the piece of brain into the pan? Was it cut?

#ReReleaseTheBrainCuttingCut

Edit: corrected a mistake in the order of shots I described.

u/Artorias_O — 12 days ago

Does Hannibal lose an eye near the end of Hannibal (novel)?

I saw these fan art drawings when I was curious about what Hannibal Lecter was imagined looking like by other readers and I came across this one. I haven't read the novel in probably a few years, so I can't remember exactly what happens during the showdown at Verger's pig farm beat-for-beat, just the general major big things. I may have just forgotten, so I can't recall him losing an eye. What exactly happens to him in regard to that?

u/Dry_Flounder_819 — 11 days ago