r/MagyarDNS

Even the base ratios are ever changing and off / Még az alap arányok is folyton változnak, és pontatlanok

First Picture is my Dads results he and all of his documented Ancestors (130 people) are from North-East Hungary (South Borsod County), Second picture is mine my Mom is half Russian but idk her ancestry

Az első kép az édesapám eredménye, ő és minden dokumentált őse (130 ember) Északkelet-Magyarországról (Dél-Borsod megyéből) származik, a második kép az enyém, az édesanyám félig orosz, de az ő származását nem ismerem

My grandmother is Hungarian- my mother's mother and here is her results-

The strange thing is if I were to see these results first I would think they are the most accurate but this is the least like stable result out of all of them- like polish matches- my mother had a massive chunk of north east polish just to get it sucked into Slovakia- and that's long way away- and I had Baltic's at some point and she did- it seems to have broken the chain of continuity-

Also I thought that Korea was just Hungarian but she does actually have Korean matches so that's strange-

It goes-

mine old

Mine new

Mother's new

Mother's old

Me half British and half Slovak and Hungarian -

Super high Carpathian results:

N1 is my grandpas sister half from
Bremen half Bavaria, closest population on G25 is Central German

Second one is me, my closest pops on G25 are south/central German

And last my grandma closest to south German on G25 yet pretty much 90% eastern now

As some of you know, I am half-Hungarian, and half-German (minor English/Irish).

Having seen enough Hungarian results now, the pattern is clear; Hungarians get a little bit of this, a little bit of that, a touch of Bulgarian, a splash of Western Turkey haha. It's disappointing that the new Hungarian regions aren't doing more of the heavy lifting.

The SideView 2.0 does a nice job separating my parental sides, almost all of the C&EE and Balkan (and Western Turkey :)) is assigned to my Hungarian side. My matches are split well too. But... the grandparent inheritance is a total bust. My Hungarian grandparents are mostly Unassigned. I think this feature will require a very high number of matches to work. I only have ~2,300 matches on my Hungarian side.

My German side is an improvement compared to last time. But it still suffers from too much scattering and proxies. Northeast Italy is probably my Tyrolean ancestry, France and Swiss are really just my Southern German ancestry, Denmark my NW German, etc. My English/Irish ancestry is one of the more impressive aspects of this result, I have distant ancestors from Cornwall and Northern Ireland, and it seems that Ancestry did a good job identifying that.

Overall, I'm disappointed that results are even crazier for Hungarians than before.

As far as ethnicity estimates, I think 23andMe is still the best for Hungarians.

The update is way better for me, those massive swings were needed. We know of some Armenian heritage so Western Turkey makes sense (though it's higher than it should be). Belgium is the only odd one out.

Megjött a családunkban a frissités… hát… szörnyű lett. Nagyon drasztikusan lecsökkent a német százalék nálam is meg anyámnál is. Anyám apukája nagyrészt sváb de van heidebauer őse is meg valamennyi magyar is. Anyai ágáról sokat nem tudok, de nagyon valószínű ott is volt sváb ős. Eddig anyámnál a német százalék 55-58% körül mozgott minden frissitéssel, nálam 32-34-40% körül apámnak 10-15-18% körül(azon az ágon is van néhány német ősöm de nem sok, anyámnak meg rengeteg német őse volt)
Eredményeink sorrendben: 1. Enyém 2. Anyámé 3. Apámé

So it seems like an unpopular opinion, these results are super accurate for my family history. I was predicting something like 70%+ western carpathian for my granduncle because the vast majority of his ancestors are from there.

I’m quite shocked at how little Bavarian remained in our results though. I also expected a stronger Croatian reading. The western Czechia seems to be coming from both sides but that + Poland could partially reflect his 2x great grandpa from opava.

I also included my dad’s results (half southern Italian) and mine (1/2 Irish, 1/4 Italian as well)

Dél-Fejér, legtöbb felmenőm nem hagyta el a környéket. Egyik nagyanyám móri sváb volt, az ő felmenőit sikerült visszakutatni az 1500-as évekig Baden-Württembergbe. Másik nagyanyám pedig a vezetékneve és szóhasználata alapján szintén sváb családból származott. Családi pletyka alapján édesanyám vezetékneve olasz származású, de a teszt eredménye alapján se húzok konklúziót, családfakutatással fogom ezt megfejteni.

fyi: im half Afghan Pashtun half Romanian/Roma/Hungarian

the update feels so rushed and contradictive

Apparently we have DNA from everywhere except Hungary itself lol

Biological mother from Hungary and maternal grandparents also from Hungary. I thought I would have more Hungarian. I feel like my heritage is more accurate

Closer to Austrians than to Transylvanian Hungarians. Uralic language, but genetically closest to Slovenes and Croats.

Your own DNA Distance Heatmap at: https://exploreyourdna.com/Store/HeatmapMaps - Works with GEDmatch, G25, or raw data files.