r/ScarletHollow

I just finished ep 5, and i laughed so much on the choice >!where sybil can give you a trait if you let her slime kaneeka!<

Imagine seeing the horrors that went through all these days and when the >!evil ass witch asks you to leave her be for a wish and you just go "can you make me really hot?"!<

Really, every other option i get it, but imagine just choosing to >!become hot rather than saving your friend!<

Pretty much the title. My first run as a street smart, animal speaker ended with Tabby and Stella trying to jail me and Tabby getting dragged into a standoff as a result. It’s clear my run is going to end badly as my allies were: the entity i’m supposed to be sacrificed to, Dr. Munchausen, and Kaneeka. I want revenge for that run ideally with book smart, mystical,keen eye or talk to animals.

https://preview.redd.it/xc8yryfis92h1.png?width=2559&format=png&auto=webp&s=7a322c208d51ada268ac7cba32cd9956de7e0dbb

So I love Wayne's freaky protectiveness of me and I flirted with him and he gave me a kiss, only it wasn't exactly a kiss, Idk what it was but it was freaky and intimate and I love it okay?

i’m reading maggie’s grave and feel there’s a few similarities but i want that horror thriller element but that has heart and fantasy

I was trying to think of neat Tattoo ideas, but the only serious idea that I could come up with was a leaf… any other ideas?

I was really trying to think of ways to commemorate my love for this game as a tattoo. Would love some suggestions ☺️

I just finished episode one and I want to continue playing but I know how I am with these kinds of games. I'd like to do a full playthrough all together instead of waiting for each episode to drop before being able to continue

As mentioned above i am playing scarlet hollow again with a friend of mine, we are currently at episode 4 on a keen eye and booksmart Playthrough and i am Considering doing another playthrough with Mystical and TTA with her before we play episode 5, cause of all the mystery and buildup that would be lost, I.e some of the stuff with the entity, Sybil, Episode 3 etc, Should i?

https://preview.redd.it/428z0qjq5z1h1.png?width=1355&format=png&auto=webp&s=1fceeb9cec1240f65fd5da6cbfc12a57ad4bdd9e

likeee this line makes me GIDDY every time i read it fjhjfhgjhg i flirt with him on every playthrough

I'm genuinely curious because I'm not into horror and I consider myself pretty sensitive but I don't find anything scary about the supernatural elements of SH. I find the Ditchlings pretty gross and some things about Reese's and Sybil's stories were disturbing, but nothing actually frightening. The only "scary" thing for me really was the >!mine collapse!<, especially the element of >!reckless teens getting themselves killed!<. A friend of mine (30 y/o male) is *really* spooked by the Ditchlings but to me they're just weird little cartoon guys? It made me wonder what the general audience reaction is.

View Poll

Keeping the title vague to avoid spoilers for episode five. Even though it's been three months now, better safe than sorry. But to go into more detail, this post is more of a fun fact, in which five of the eight romanceable characters can die, so far!

From my recollection...

Avery: can die in episode five in the climax (at the farm). There's one outcome variation where Julius accidentally shoots them, and they die from the gunshot wound.

Joan: can die in episode four in the climax. Reese can eat her.

Kaneeka: this one is a little complicated since she doesn't die in the traditional sense. But I'll still count it because being absorbed by the Witch means she'll be stuck in her forever. Anyway, she can die in episode five in the other climax (Witch's world) via the Witch absorbing her.

Reese: can die in episode four in the climax. You and Tabitha can burn him alive after she uses her shotgun to level him.

Sybil: in the same vein as Kaneeka, I'll count her being absorbed as a death. In episode five, in the other climax (Witch's world), you can use Mystical trait save to make Kaneeka the new witch, allowing her to absorb Sybil.

This leaves Oscar, Stella, and Wayne. I think all three of them could die in a future episode.

Oscar could die if he chooses to flee the town or enter the still-haunted town hall.

Stella could die in episode six during the climax, which I also predict will involve Gretchen.

Wayne could die in episode seven during the climax. I believe he's the Entity, and he's being set up as a final boss type (assuming you're not on his side). With that in mind, there's a high chance there'll be an ending to eliminate him from the world forever.

What does everyone else think?