r/ShopifyAppMarketing

Image 1 — Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback
Image 2 — Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback
Image 3 — Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback
Image 4 — Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback
Image 5 — Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback
▲ 1 r/ShopifyAppMarketing+1 crossposts

Shopify rejected my app over a field I never asked permission for, now it's live with 8 installs and I'm looking for brutal feedback

Solo founder, data engineer background. Spent about two months building Margeny, profit margin analytics for Shopify stores. Submitted to App Store review, got rejected.

The official reason was "error importing data, blocks the review." Took me a whole afternoon to find the real one. My queries were requesting customer email, which is Protected Customer Data on Shopify and needs explicit approval I hadn't asked for. The annoying part is dev stores are exempt from that restriction, so every single test I ran passed fine. It only broke the moment a real store touched it, which for a reviewer is the first time that happens.

Fixed it, resubmitted, got approved. It's live now.

Where I'm at: 8 installs, 0 reviews yet. Early enough that I'm still figuring out if the onboarding actually makes sense to someone who isn't me. It calculates real margin per order, COGS, payment fees, shipping, refunds, and cross references ad spend so you get profit after ads instead of just gross revenue.

If anyone here has a few minutes to poke at it and tell me what's confusing, missing, or just not worth paying for, I'd genuinely rather hear that now than after 50 installs. Not fishing for a nice review, actual criticism is more useful to me right now.

apps.shopify.com/margeny

u/Outrageous-Fennel552 — 24 hours ago
▲ 1 r/ShopifyAppMarketing+1 crossposts

Looking for a few Shopify merchants to try my app and tell me where it sucks

I've been building a Shopify app for a while and I'm at the point where I need people to actually use it instead of me sitting there convincing myself that everything makes sense.

The app is still pretty rough around the edges. There are definitely things I need to improve, and that's actually what I'm trying to figure out right now.

One thing I'm particularly interested in is how easy it is to understand and get started with.

I'm a developer, so there's always a risk that something feels obvious to me but makes absolutely no sense to someone who isn't technical. I've tried to hide as much of the underlying complexity as possible and keep the experience focused on what merchants actually need to do.

So I'd really like to know:

  • Can you understand what the app does without me explaining it?
  • Is the onboarding straightforward?
  • Are there places where you get stuck or don't know what to do next?
  • Does the terminology make sense?
  • Does it actually help you get something useful out of your store data?

It's completely free right now. I'm mainly looking for a handful of early beta users who are willing to try it and give me honest feedback.

And if I eventually monetize it, I'll make sure the people who join during this early beta stay free forever.

I'm not expecting the app to be polished yet. In fact, I'd prefer people who are willing to tell me "this makes no sense" or "I expected this to do X" because that's exactly the kind of feedback I'm looking for.

If you're interested, comment here or DM me and I'll send you access.

I'd genuinely appreciate the help.

reddit.com
u/Suitable_Ranger2512 — 3 days ago
▲ 3 r/ShopifyAppMarketing+1 crossposts

What's one thing about running a store nobody warned you about?

Started my store a while back and the thing that's surprised me most isn't the product or the ads, it's how much time goes into stuff nobody talks about: customer emails, small site bugs, chasing reviews.

Curious what caught other people off guard when they actually started.

reddit.com
u/aov_andy — 5 days ago
▲ 6 r/ShopifyAppMarketing+6 crossposts

Launched Gamopanda - Loyalty Gamification Platform

Hi, While all legacy loyalty software offers points as a medium for customer retention, I launched Gamopanda last month with a focus on gamification with features such as Streaks, Challenges, Milestones and Rewards. The roadmap includes Missions, Badges and Leaderboards.

I believe the future is Gamification, which can inculcate habits in a user to visit a brand multiple times increasing customer retention and ultimately revenue.

I would like to hear honest feedback from the community and being a solo founder/engineer, I would like to know how to crack the distribution of the software. Currently we are available on Shopify and Wix app stores and being API first, it can be integrated anywhere be it Hospitality, Hotels, Restaurants, Gaming, etc.

gamopanda.com
u/Old-Valuable-1763 — 5 days ago

is shopify agencies partnership worth it?

anyone here tried a partnership with shopify agencies to get some users? i'm planning to do a prtnership program and share 30% from the revenue retreived from merchants they bring , what do u think?

reddit.com
u/fatah_lbk — 11 days ago

Need Advice to Grow My New B2B Shopify Request a Quote & Hide Price App

Hello everyone,

I recently launched my Shopify app:

Ez Request a Quote, Hide Price

I'd really appreciate advice from developers who have successfully grown a Shopify app.

Specifically:

  • How did you get your first 10–20 merchants?
  • Which marketing channels gave you the best ROI?
  • Is content marketing worth investing in for Shopify apps?
  • Are agency partnerships actually effective?
  • Anything you wish you had done earlier?

I'm not looking for shortcuts. just trying to learn what actually works for a new Shopify SaaS.

Any advice or lessons would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you! 🙂

reddit.com
u/EffectiveJumpy1408 — 13 days ago