r/Vanderpumpaholics

I'm rewatching the season 5 reunion and they show that clip of Andy asking the chefs who is the most good looking woman at SUR. The chef says Katie, and the other one nods. Andy pulls a surprised face, and says "interesting", then he asks them what they think about Lala. This was so shitty of him to do. Like he couldn't believed they would think Katie. If I was someone struggling with self esteem like Katie was many times, throughout this show, that would have cut me. He just seems like a proper knob.

I’ve been rewatching VPR and I need to know what everyone actually thinks was true vs. complete bull.

There are so many allegations on this show that were never really resolved and then years later something else happens that makes you look back at an old rumor completely differently.
Some of the ones I keep thinking about on my rewatch.

James cheating on Raquel — how many times do we actually think this happened?? There was Lala, Hope, Logan, the girl from Coachella and Ellie.

James and Kristen in Mexico —The whole Pillowgate.
What do you guys actually believe happened?

Sandoval and Billie Lee — Was there actually something there?? Billie and Tom always seemed extremely close and then the rumor came out during Scandoval, Tom also admitted there was another woman he cheated with before Raquel and never really identified her. Do we think Billie was that woman or was it the girl he was smoking with on the balcony during guys night with Dayna before she joined the cast.

Sandoval + Ariana while he was with Kristen — obviously we know they eventually got together but I still think the timeline was way messier than they wanted people to believe. How much do we think actually happened before the Vegas story?

Schwartz cheating on Katie — I believe he cheated WAY more than we ever actually saw. The “I was blackout drunk” excuse seems so fake. We know about Mexico and the other women but how many more were there?

Jax + Lala — Do we think this happened?

Lala being a side chick/mistress — obviously she was involved with Randall while he was still married but I’m talking about all the other accusations from that era. The “BJs for PJs,” private jet, yachting, being paid to hang out with wealthy men stuff.

Jax + anyone — Do we think Faith was the only person Jax cheated on Brittany with?

How early did Sandoval and Raquel actually start?
Because now that we know the full Scandoval story, I can’t watch Seasons 9 and 10 the same. There are so many little things that suddenly seem suspicious.

What do you think actually happened?

I’m watching season 11 and I think Scheana is a good friend.