r/YouTubeThumbnailHub

Image 1 — Thumbnail Critique for Minecraft Video - Which Thumbnail would implore you to click?
Image 2 — Thumbnail Critique for Minecraft Video - Which Thumbnail would implore you to click?

Thumbnail Critique for Minecraft Video - Which Thumbnail would implore you to click?

Title (Working): I’ve Played Minecraft for 15 Years, But Never Beat the Ender Dragon 

Context / Summary: The premise of the video is my first try at beating the Ender Dragon (alone) despite playing Minecraft for 15 years at this point.

The number in the title would be the emotional/curiousity hook of "wtf do you mean you've never beaten Minecraft despite playing it for 15 years?". Hopefully that would be enough to have the viewer click to see the journey of said accomplishment.

Premise: First time fighting Ender Dragon

Problem: The prepwork to fighting the dragon, the expedition to find the stronghold, and the battle itself.

Promise/Payoff: Will I beat the Ender Dragon or not after playing this game for 15 years?

Thoughts? Questions? Suggestions? Preference of Thumbnail? Thanks!

u/HammHammVT — 5 days ago

Need some help with this thumbnail please!

Title: Hellraiser Revival With 20FPS Was A TERRIBLE IDEA!

Summary: Playing the demol of the game, but because my laptop sucks tit, I could only play with 20-30 fps, making for some funny moments. I decided to embrace it and use it to make my gameplay stand out from other tubers. Tried to embrace it in the thumbnail!

Not sure about whether to add the text or go no text for this one...

u/Lumpy_Ad9191 — 5 days ago

How would you rate this thumbnail from 1 to 10?

Video Title: "Thomas Edison Loves Me. Here’s Why."
Video description: "A person who has destroyed Edison's life, but he thinks he has helped him be successfull"

u/Upstairs_Emu_2343 — 14 days ago

Is it a bad idea to run a thumbnail test on a small channel?

First off, please provide feedback on these thumbnails.

Second...

I have 4 versions of a thumbnail that I want to test. All pretty similar, just the big word at the bottom changed. But I've noticed in the past (I'm a small channel, <700 subs) that running a thumbnail test seemed to be a bad idea, because I barely get exposure to begin with, it then shows a thumbnail that doesnt perform well to people, stops showing to people, and then tells me it doesnt have enough data to even tell me which thumbnail won, which makes ZERO sense.

I've had videos with 1k views within the 2 week period and it still tell me it didn't have enough data to tell me what thumbnail won, and hardly ever reach that mark. So it seems like a sure-fire way to make my video not perform well. Am I crazy?

Video Title:

Considering between these 3:

Wormholes, Stargates, Mind Control & MORE (Newly Declassified UFO Files

Warp Drives, Wormholes, Antigravity & MORE: Newly Declassified UFO Files

UAP Materials Recovered? Intelligent UAPs? (NEW Declassified UFO Files)

Video Description:

I make a video no each batch of the UFO Files. This one discusses the 6th batch dropped last week. There were videos released, but I focus on the documents such as 37 reference documents from a govt classified UFO program known as AAWSAP that reviewed the current research on frontier scientific topics: Antigravity, Negative Energy, Wormholes/Warp Drives, Extra Dimensions, Mind Control of Spacecraft, just to name a few. The military document has a section for the observer to fill out a section about if any UAP materials were recovered, if it was under intelligent control, what physical state was it, etc. That's the background behind my thumbnail ideas.

u/Jolly_Echo806 — 14 days ago
▲ 11 r/YouTubeThumbnailHub+3 crossposts

Feedback on my thumbnail for a K-drama fight compilation? Does "ONE VS EVERYONE" grab you?

Hey everyone, I'm about to upload a long-form fight compilation from a K-drama (Weak Hero Class 1 Season 1, all 8 episodes). It's pure fights with fast editing and commentary I made the thumbnail and would love honest feedback before I publish

What I was going for:

  • Big, bold text with a "ONE VS EVERYONE" hook to show the underdog-vs-crowd story
  • A bruised, bloodied character with a crowd behind him for emotion
  • A small "ALL FIGHTS" tag in the corner to show what the video is

What I'm unsure about:

  1. Is the text readable at small mobile sizes?
  2. Is "ALL FIGHTS" too small or too hidden in the corner?
  3. Is the image too blurry or dark? Would a sharper or brighter frame work better?
  4. Would you click this? If not, what would make you click?

I'm open to blunt criticism Thanks in advance!

u/animefans111 — 14 days ago

Any feedback or advice on this thumbnail? Trying to really nail it this time

Video Title: "I Wasn't Ready For This | Idaho's Sawtooth Mountains"

*No AI was used in this, just good old Photoshop*

This is for a hiking/adventure video focusing on the Sawtooth Mountains in Idaho. I really stepped up my editing on the video so I'm following suite and trying to step up my thumbnail game as well. Any advice or feedback would be appreciated!

u/ycameron180 — 14 days ago

advise on the thumbnail

Title - How this Disease is the Perfect Heart Killer | Lupus & Your Heart

Hello Everyone,

Thanks for all the support and advise for all the thumbnails so far, if you could kindly lend your thoughts on this one. Not made with AI, images were taken from canva image library.

Summary - the video explains about effects of the disease lupus on the heart.

u/Spirited_Grocery3753 — 14 days ago