r/mtgbrawl

Looking for Spicy Underrated Competitive Brawl Decks
▲ 25 r/mtgbrawl+1 crossposts

Looking for Spicy Underrated Competitive Brawl Decks

I have a YouTube channel [https://youtube.com/@dangergamez0\] where I focus on exploring Competitive Brawl and was looking for some spicy decks. I have hit most of the obvious meta contenders but I am looking for lists with underrated and underrepresented Commanders that people have had success with in Competitive Brawl.

I love this format and really just want to explore what's possible and this community continues to come up with awesome ideas

I do like to cite my sources, so if anyone has some spice they wanted to show off please feel free to share your lists.

Edit: wow!! You guys definitely delivered the spice. I am going to do my best to keep this thread up to date as I work my way through the long list of decks to try. Thank you everyone!

u/Spaceman-Mars — 6 days ago

Part 2: Cards that should be banned in Brawl because they hurt my feelings.

Hello.

This is a follow up to my first post, Decks that should be banned in Brawl because I do not like them.

I have just ended an unsuccessful game with my brand new, barely tested 5c plansewalker pile, and my opponent rudely played a mono black deck that worked. This is mean and should be stopped, but I digress.

The following is a list of more decks/cards that should be banned because they made me feel inadequate:

  • [[Ardyn the Usurper]]: The realest pick on this list, Ardyn is a bullshit card and I hate it. It's the secret commander of every [[Old Stickfingers]] deck, alongside [[Ulamog the defiler]], which is how i feel after playing against it. Why does it give the token HASTE, WotC?! ANSER for your crimes.

  • Decks that primarily use "Sacrifice a creature" as their removal: My creature has indestructible, Hexproof and ward 20. I want it to stay on the battlefield, and making it go away is rude and unfun.

  • Decks that play at Flash speed: Just because [[Teferi, Time Raveler]] got reverted to it's paper version does NOT mean you should play it against me. That is bullying and I WILL call the cyber police

  • [[Krenko]]: Do I really need to explain?

  • Decks that are Discard tribal and/Or theft tribal: this is a partial repeat, but they are MY cards I PAID for them I want to PLAY them.

  • [[Hei Bai]]: He's still bullshit.

  • [[Rofellos]]: No one should be allowed to have THAT much green mana on turn 3.

  • Black creatures that have haste: Look i didn't expect you to be playing [[Rankle]] and I planned around my [[Teferi, Time Raveler]] to still be on the field on my turn. You should be ashamed of yourself.

  • [[Sheoldred, The Apocalypse]]: see [[Krenko]]

Cards that can be removed from the list:

  • [[Cosmic Spider Man]]: he stopped being a problem after everyone got the Achievement, but for real, what the fuck man.

As always, this list is not exhaustive, and will be updated in the future as WotC continues to print cards targeted at making specifically me have a bad time.

Thank you for your time.

reddit.com
u/The_Palm_of_Vecna — 11 days ago

Grist top #100 gameplay

I know a lot of people are looking for top-tier gameplay videos, so I'm going to try and make a few with decks perfectly capable of holding the tier 1 commanders of cBrawl. The gameplay is about 3 weeks old, but the decklist in the description is updated and will continue to be: https://moxfield.com/decks/w7GWTQi-uEGv-cuNZ-eu4g

I sped it up and added a voice-over to make it less boring to watch. Hope you like it ♥️

youtu.be
u/Skullsbreaker52 — 12 days ago

Bad Matchmaking?

So I’ve got this pretty bad but fun Syr Gwyn deck, very slow. I don’t have any more rare wildcards so it’s mostly commons and uncommons. For a while it would match me with decks that are usually better but I still had a chance at winning. And some would be really even and fun.

All day yesterday it’s just been matching me up against decks that completely take over the game by turn 3/4 a lot of them are the new commanders from Reality Fracture.

Like am I missing something or should I just never play this deck now? I thought there was some sort of weighting scale for this

reddit.com
u/harleybarley — 11 days ago

When you get crushed but it was by an interesting commander choice

u/acabho — 11 days ago