
Controversial oOpinion: A vote against boycotting Israeli products is a vote for business as usual in Israel.
Edited/Updated:
I've heard and read people's thoughts on why they oppose the boycott and the vary from an emotional attachment to Israel, fear that it will alienate pro-Israel members, claiming they don't want to disrupt the sense of community (clarification on this would be good since it otherwise sounds abstract and vague, despite disagreements the co-op continues to function and grow), a commitment to zionism, concerns over a possible economic and reputational fallout, etc.
But here is the message that not boycotting Israeli products sends to people like me: that the coop is indifferent or in support of: pogroms against Palestinians in the West Bank; the indiscriminate bombing of civilian homes and infrastructure in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran; a continued apartheid system for Palestinians in the occupied territories and Jerusalem; denial of Palestinian refugees' right of return under international law; support for the extremist Netanyahu/Ben-Gvir administration; indifference or disdain for non-zionist co-op members.
If I am wrong I hope people will educate me on what that is. I don't see how anyone at this point in time can argue in good faith that dialogue and a two-state solution is the only way forward. Particularly when the Israeli government and electorate have made it clear they are not interested in dialogue and will never allow for the existence of sovereign Palestinian state. This is clear from the Israeli government's efforts to expand settlements and enforce policies designed to make life impossible for Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank.
A boycott is the only non-violent way of putting pressure on Israel to respect the very international laws and entities (like the UN) that made the state possible. At least until there is significant political shift in the US and our politicians cease to provide billions in funding and backing Israel in the UN.
Update - the Jewish Daily Forward published this about the boycott debate, which I think clarifies the fact the coop has always been "political" and not just a grocery store: https://forward.com/culture/826654/park-slope-food-coop-boycott-israel-palestine-bds/