r/schoolforgoodandevil

Just wondering, how feasible is it that Yara is a trans girl? (with some points as I am a believer)

Was rereading the book series, and I just finished book 2! This is something that I've just been thinking about a lot.

Just gonna list out some key things from books 1&2

Book 1: Trying to conform to masculinity

+ Constantly trying to emulate Tedros, the embodiment of perfect masculinity and princely behavior at the School for Good

+ Chasing after Beatrix, the ideal girl in the School for Good, like every other Everboy

+ At the Trial for Tale, asking out Kiko (as she clearly has feelings, and again, is expected behavior)

Book 2: More freedom

+ Tedros is no longer the gold standard, as he is the cause for the shameful situation the School for Boys find themselves in (although Yara still stays a friend)

+ Yara is an outsider at both the School for Boys and Girls, but at Boys feels out of place and disliked while at Girls, is recognized for who she is, even though other girls still speculate and gossip about her unique traits (kinda i guess you could look at it as not being able to fully pass? *but also she is also a "new" student at the school)

+ Aric (evil gay{?} but definitely has a STRONG dislike for girls) always hated her

+ When she is dying, she says "I'm not Yara," which I view as her saying that they know her by a different name, even if it is not necessarily the name that she prefers (and specifically chooses not to use in the sentence)

+ She also thanks Tedros for supporting her and being a good friend

+ Part of my thoughts too is that literally every person in the School for Boys hated the place, but Yara is the only one to go to the School for Girls, and is willing to be used by Dean Sader just to be able to exist as a girl in the school

+ But in the end, this is all just speculation, and it's not like anything is officially confirmed (at least nothing that I know about)

reddit.com

SGE X DND

Hii! I'm creating a homebrew campaign in DnD based on the SGE book series, it's gonna take place about 13 years after the 6th book.

Do you guys have any ideas for adventures or plots?

I'm thinking thwy should attend school as normal untill a distruptive force breaks through the Woods like a plague, forcing our heros to go venture the Woods and its kingdoms

All ideas are welcomed and appriciated😊

u/LillHoneydew — 4 days ago

A Crystal of Time Bonus Chapter

I recently bought a second hand copy of the target edition of ACOT. It wasn't available where I live when it was released so I'm really glad I found it because it includes a bonus chapter called 'Friends and Foes'.>! It follows Sophie after she tells all the Woods leaders that Rhian is the true king because Robin Hood tells her to make Rhian think she's on his side. In this chapter though, the note was different. It told Sophie to meet Robin in the white tower (the room where Evelyn and Lady Gremlaine were going to trick Arthur). Sophie then finds the Sheriff's sack and enters it, where she meets the Sheriff, Robin, and Guinevere. To be honest, the chapter was mostly a recap of what had happened when the pirates attacked the School and the Sheriff saved the students, so it doesn't add much to the plot. They recap the One True King theory. The Sheriff explains how the sack was enchanted by Rafal, he mentions Dot saving Robin from jail, Guinevere talks about the birds she sings to which get Robin's attention, and all of this is explained at some other point in the book.!<

>!There was a lot of interesting world-building though. For example, Sophie notices a chest labelled 'Foxwood Steel', which gives the King of Foxwood a motive for his support for Rhian since he provides the steel that Rhian uses for his army. I think this is brought up briefly when Hort and Nicola go to Foxwood.!<

>!The sack itself is really interesting. It's split into a side for 'Friends' and a side for 'Foes'. When Sophie first enters, she's guided by the fairies she saw in Sherwood Forest into the 'Friends' side. There, everyone sees a different version of a happy place. Sophie sees her room in the School Master's tower the Sheriff sees Nottingham, Robin sees Marian's Arrow, and Guinevere sees her and Lancelot's old house. In the 'Foes' side, everyone sees their worst fears. This is where Kei and the pirates are imprisoned. At one point, Kei tries to break free from his prison but then a fairy stings him and he falls still like he's seen a ghost (I wonder what his worst fear is? Feel free to speculate about this). Sophie and the others go to this side and they all see the same thing: Tedros and the prisoners' execution. She also sees Agatha, Hort, the Coven, and all the other students looking down at the same scene because they're all in the sack too. They don't see her and the Sheriff makes sure they don't because that might change the scene they're all sharing. They're using this scene to predict and plan for the future. Then it ends with Sophie and Agatha getting a brief glimpse of each other before Sophie returns to Camelot and tries to make Rhian think she's only his side!<.

Soman leaves a few notes to explain why he cut it out, which is quite an interesting look into his writing process. I don't think it's a necessary chapter so I can see why he left it out. I did enjoy getting more SGE content though.

u/Kindly_Implement65 — 5 days ago

Tedros and Guinevere

So I was thinking about Tedros and his relationship with his mother in the books, because they didn’t give him the character depth in the move. In my opinion I don’t think he really forgave her for abandoning him and his father. Also that was why he was so guarded in the beginning of the series was mainly because of her.

reddit.com
u/Life_Scene8420 — 14 days ago