TIFU by shouting “You deflowered the butter!” at dinner with the Archbishop of Atlanta
This happened about 20 years ago, shortly after my wife and I got married.
My wife helped teach confirmation classes at our Catholic church. Each year, after the students were confirmed, the priest would invite the volunteers to dinner at the rectory.
That year, the Archbishop of Atlanta was in town and joined us for dinner.
There were about eight of us total, including my wife, the priest, and the Archbishop.
Dinner was served family style. Everyone got up to fill their plates in the kitchen and then returned to the dining room table.
My wife and I were already seated while the priest and Archbishop were still in the kitchen getting their food.
On the table were little decorative pats of butter shaped like flowers.
My wife picked up her knife and cut into one.
Without thinking, I said, loud enough for everyone at the table to hear:
“Susan!(fake name) You deflowered the butter!”
Fortunately, the priest and Archbishop were still in the kitchen and didn’t hear me.
My wife, however, was not amused.
Twenty years later, I still maintain it was a solid joke.
TL;DR: At my first dinner with Catholic clergy, I loudly accused my new wife of “deflowering the butter.”