Grieving the life I planned as a Christian and coming to terms with the fact that I am gay
TW: self-harm ideation.
(28M) Really difficult to say this, but I think I am mourning the life I had planned. Grew up Evangelical Christian in Mexico. Not too religious family, but still very involved in the church I used to attend. This church is a semi-cult, and I was completely aware of that and stopped meeting when I was in college, but after the pandemic and all the social influence I ended up meeting again there and eventually attending the church's seminary (I graduated in December 2025). The issue is that this was the peak of myself trying to belong to somewhere I simply don't belong, and right now I feel like crap with all the ongoing situation and my friends moving on.
For context, when I realized I was gay in college, I simply started dating guys and didn't care at all about religious things. I started exploring other beliefs and seldom going to church. But when I finished college in 2020, I decided to leave "the gay world behind" and I cut off al contact with a guy I was hooking up with. I prayed to God that I didn't want to live that life anymore, but then eventually everything hit. I started having a very obscure episode of paranoia. I was thinking about harming myself all the time and eventually I ended up taking Aripipazole (an antipsychotic) and going to therapy for three years. Somehow I managed to continue my life for a few years.
In 2023, I dated a guy from another country. The pastors from my church told me around those days to stop dating men, but I continued talking to him for a few months. It didn't end up well and I was very disappointed with myself for all the internal homophobia that over the years I have been cultivating. I was depressive for several months, until I decided to join the seminary, because I thought that was going to pray the gay away. Of course it didn't work like that.
In 2025, I became friends with a guy from the seminary. A friend of mine (Female) told me this guy sent her messages a few years ago, so I didn't suspect anything from this person. He was very homophobic but our friendship was slowly turning "strange". He would say often that he wanted to get married after graduating, but he would lift up my pants when we were studying, hugging me, touching my belly from time to time. I ended up falling in love, again, with this person, a man. I was terribly sad and disappointed because I thought that in seminary I would finally become straight. After graduating he started dating a girl, I ended up coming out to him (I didn't tell him I was in love with him) and he stopped talking to me after that. Anyway I feel much better of not talking to him, because I think there were mixed signals during our friendship(?).
I have been in therapy for a few months. I think I have an obsession to become validated with the church I grew up in. That is all my social circle and, as a semi-cult, is hard to move on from there. I still live in Mexico, but I am thinking about moving somewhere else. I have told myself many many times that I will become more transparent with myself and more authentic. I had the opportunity of working in the church, but I declined since it was for me a way to continue with the mask. I'm open to my secular friends and parents, but I still think very often that this is a lie. I haven't cheated on anyone of course, but I think I no longer fit. The church was all my identity, so I feel very hollow right now. I'm still processing all that I have lived these years, and progressively accepting myself and grieving for the life I had planned as a Christian. Any advice?