I can’t tell if I truly regret her or if I’m stuck in limerence obsession
Hi everyone,
I’m 31, and about 10 months ago I got out of a 6-year relationship that had become pretty toxic (and I can now clearly see my own responsibility in that too). Even though I moved on from the relationship itself relatively quickly, it was still a massive life rupture: living together, plans to buy a place, an entire future built around that relationship.
Very soon after the breakup, I developed an extremely intense attachment to the first girl I met. Looking back, it almost felt irrational, like my brain was desperately trying to replace what I had lost.
The issue is that she was very emotionally avoidant / independent, so things took a long time to really develop between us. During that time, I met another girl, and with her everything felt simple, natural, stable and easy from the start.
I ended up seeing both of them in parallel for a while, naïvely thinking my feelings would eventually become clear on their own. Instead, it completely destroyed me mentally: insomnia, obsessive thoughts, constant comparisons, inability to think clearly. There’s a Rohmer quote that kept coming back to me: “He who has two women loses his soul.” Honestly, I feel like I experienced exactly that.
About two and a half months ago, I finally ended things with the first girl. Not in the best way, to be honest — I was psychologically overwhelmed. And right at that moment, she finally opened up emotionally and told me she was ready to commit more seriously. The worst part is that I can’t even really blame her for waiting so long, because I had never clearly communicated with her about what we actually were to each other.
But what she told me at that moment was exactly what I had wanted to hear for months.
Since then, I’ve stayed with the second girl. Objectively, the relationship is healthy. When I’m with her, I genuinely feel good, calm, even happy. But whenever I’m alone, my mind goes straight back to the first story. I replay everything endlessly, compare both relationships constantly, and I feel like it’s poisoning my present relationship.
So now I’m completely lost about what I’m actually feeling:
- do I genuinely regret losing the first girl?
- or am I just trapped in a mental loop fueled by emotional intensity, uncertainty, guilt, and the unfinished nature of that relationship?
Because there’s also a lot of guilt involved. I know I hurt her, and I’m not trying to paint myself as the victim here. But honestly, this whole situation has also deeply messed me up psychologically.
I’ve even started wondering whether there’s something deeper going on mentally. Sometimes it feels like I made certain decisions in a kind of emotionally manic state, and that for the last 2–3 months I’ve crashed into something closer to depression, full of regret and this constant feeling of “it’s too late now.”
I’m not looking for a Reddit diagnosis obviously. I’m mostly trying to understand whether other people have experienced this kind of fixation after an intense and unfinished relationship, even while being in a healthier and more stable one.
Thanks to anyone who took the time to read.