u/Aldabon

Hi everyone, It’s been a while since I last took counterpoint lessons, so I’ve been trying to keep practicing on my own. As an exercise, I took the bass line from Bach chorales and wrote a new chorale on top of it. This one is based on chorale No. 3 from the 371 chorales. I wasn’t aiming to be completely strict with the Baroque style; rather, I used it as a starting point and allowed myself to incorporate some of my own ideas when it felt appropriate. I’d really appreciate any feedback, especially on voice leading, harmony, and any spots that feel weak or unidiomatic