Are Pakistani ex muslims obsessed with Islam? Or are muslims being biased

Pakistani people can kill ex muslims. Although them killing ex muslim is not guaranteed but its not guaranteed that they will let exmuslim live.

Pakistan has a history that tends towards killing ex muslims.

Pakistani law doesn't allows ex muslims to represent their new religion in ID card. The id card keeps saying muslim.

Pakistani law will assign Islam as religion to Id card of ex muslim children. Creating murtid death threat for children too

Islam itself orders killing of ex Muslims just because they exist.

Ex muslims are not obsessed but frustrated for being trapped even after leaving Islam.

Cmon bro, let ex muslims live their lives without mental and physical persecution. A muslim in Pakistan doesn't have to face all of this on daily basis. You are not superior and nor better.

You muslims are just running the state in a biased way

Edit: the need to hide religion makes it difficult for ex Muslim to find partner. The way how kids religion is forced makes it difficult for a ex muslim to have kids.

reddit.com
u/AsiaKCKiller — 14 days ago
▲ 18 r/CritiqueIslam+1 crossposts

Islam is temporally and geographically restricted?

Prophet made prophecies. Sometimes Allah used to correct him

This didn't selectively happened in

  1. Marriage with Ayesha. 9 or 17. Still gives weapon to critics when prophet is 50
  2. Timing of adoption ending ayats after marrying adopted son divorced wife and how that divorce happened.

point 1, 2 establishes not being able to see through pr disasters & time restrictions where Islam says for all time but cant relate to modern morals while itself started as modern religion. You can claim that Islam is not obligated to pr and other stuff but reality is that claim of timeless perfection, for everyone is a pr in itself. The Islam modernized the 7th century like abandoning many things like idol worship, etc but cant relate to modern moral standards. In point 2, It shows mismanaged timing of ayats which could have came before.

You can claim some prophecies doesnt mean complete foreknowledge but reality is that it undermines timeless perfection claim. 80:1-10 did active small stakes correction to frowning incident for prophet but it was absent in point 1(high stakes) while point 2 ayat timing was convenient.

The stories, prophecies is all about middle east, rome & others. It doesn't cover whole world like east asia.A clear geo restrictions.

Quran claims itself, literally Quran itself as easy. Average muslim cant easily relate to this. They face things like

  1. learn arabic but still uncertain about what word means
  2. translations (with many versions) but uncertain if they capture the ayat spirit correctly.

4:82 asks to understand Quran deeply and not just memorizing by rot. Interpretation job is of scholars only narrative is also heavy. The reality actively undermines the Quran's claim.

Justifications for all of these requires Allah's wisdom/plans, 7th century norms, man made morals, etc which doesn't sits with Islam's claim of timeless, perfect, for all world.

The clear time and geo restrictions undermines the claim of divinely sent.

reddit.com
u/AsiaKCKiller — 3 months ago