Just finished the whole game for the first time *Spoiler*
That was a long road, I wish I've done the first 2 season without any real spoil about who dies or not (the game have what like 12 years, it was inevitable anyway💀). But it still surprised me with how their death came to be and angered me on some part (season 2 *COUGH*) but the other seasons and the 2 special (400 days and michonne) was new to me so it was somewhat great (I preferred more season 3 and 4 more than the 2 specials but ill get to that)
The first season was Great. I give it an 8/10 score because how they set the tone of the whole game, the characters especially Lee and Clem. With my own choices, I friended kenny from the start (I knew he would be a pain to deal with because of all the spoil i came across over the years but i somehwat understand his reasoning) i killed Duck (or chuck, forgot his kid name really lol), Carley's death didn't have to happen but oh welp💀, Lilly..I'll talk more about her in season 4 but I chose to still stay with us and Ben, what a character💀choosing the worst moment to talk about his feelings would be his super power in this zombie world but other than that, I think i would've done the same as him except leaving clem from my sight and trading food with other people without the say of the group. Still killed him in that Bell tower or whatever was that just to have more space in that dream boat. Christine and omid was real bro's, when I told them about my bite they all helped me, cut my arms too that was great.
Season 2..they took season 1 ideas and did everything wrong💀 I'mma try to be quick with this one or else it would take me hours upon hours, I already talked about it in an another post, i give it at most 3/10. Each point is Just because of clem as a character, kenny as a character and their ending where they seperate each other for kenny to leave me alone to stay at that base with aj. PEAK. But the rest of the characters and tone.... that was a shitshow💀 especially jane, luke and bonnie, I dont know what they smoked while making the last episode but holy. I loved jane until the last episode, that was so sad because i didn't felt anything when kenny plundged his knife in her chest, she deserved it for her "plan" or whatever that was💀Last thing WHY ARVO LIVED!?💀 PLEASE PLEEEAASE make a new season where I can find bonnie and the other guy and kill all of them. I refuse to believe they got an happy ending. I would send aj on a special mission💀
Season 3 was alright, I give it a good 5 or low end 6, I can say after season 1 and 2, they made a lot of progress but it wasn't that great, I saw there was a lot more people that you could save tho which I couldn't during my run so one day I hope to do it better. I don't think there's a lot thing to say about their characters really. Except for the boy and the mom, forgot their name sadly, in my ending the boy died following his dad which I didn't really understood, à moment ago he was praising me and say how he wasn't sure that following his had footstep was a good thing but still done it anyway like if that whole dialogue didn't matter. But I guess he was just à kid and did à kid thing. And the mom..oh my lord.. I don't know why she was so obsessed by saving the city for some reason. It's so sudden when before that she wanted to leave the city and didn't cared about the population and obviously telltale needed to make a villain so they made the brother lash out on us no matter what you do because the other girl couldn't contained her feeling like ben. I somehwat felt some regret about my ending and how I managed it but oh welp that was my season 3 and I dont mind it, next time I'll do somehwat better
Season 4 was a Masterpiece I give it a 9 or a low end 10, deserved it. The characters, the plot and AJ the goat. Gameplay wise, the fact that you can FINALLY run after 3 season felt so good holy sht. Finally I didn't spent 1 hour alone just to explore. The way that you also shape AJ perception yourself was so great, I don't really know how far it could go tho (like if I told him to kill anyone no matter what for any reason, does he become like Carver?), I'll try to experiment that in the future. The kids choices, I can tell you I got so mad when AJ killed marlon and they all wanted us gone but I saw someone talking about it in one of the post and I got less mad about it🥹 (something about they're just kids of course) and that they didn't even have time to process what marlon did etc etc.. The dream with Lee. PEAK. I left Lilly alive, that was a surprise to see her and if there was somewhat a canon storyline, I hope to see lilly and finally kill her myself not in front of AJ if it ever came to that. But other than that, that was cool what lily has done I somewhat felt pity for her about the war but still you dont steal kids. About the ending chief kiss, I was ready to play as AJ for the rest of the game with clem dead but seeing her alive because I trusted AJ? Telling him that a firefighters need to keep their cool Holy sht that felt so good💀 I didn't really cried but I did got something in my eyes for sure. Even though I dont really know how AJ managed to do that and that clem didn't transformed faster like Lee did. I'm guessing lee got a lot more time before they cut his arm thats why it was too late. Romanced louis and didn't saved violet was funny💀 didn't liked the way she acted in that cell even after the bombshell of minnie dropped about killing her own sister. At least clem didn't do that to any of them💀 that was an ending that I didn't regret at all compared to season 3 I would like to know if there's any piece of lore somewhere saying what happened to their group, what happened to AJ and Clem I would love to know.
400 days was a short one for sure, didn't really liked it because they were only just became Cameo's for nothing really major and the only people that managed to do anything leave with all the supplies that was needed for the group, especially for the baby AJ, left Clem to die in the snow after ARVO shoot for NO REASON. Really Bonnie what a Saint she is. So really..I give it more than season 2 so 4/10 really because season 2 was worse.
Michonne story was also short maybe too short in my opinion, I give it a 4/10, I didn't really sticked up to the other characters except pete and michonne. I don't know what gregg smoked believing that we were in contact with any of them for years? Did I blink and missed a dialogue? Like if he wanted to die, he could've said so in that interrogation scene, saved more time for me. Norma believing whatever she believes in, they dont know us beforehand and whatever there was in that ferry, its not like their base was in that ferry so I dont see why she believed that we stole from them. Loved sam's reaction when I snitched that it wasn't my bag. Because it litteraly wasnt The "WTF" like if I knew her before that interaction and even then I only her name not because she introduced herself but because it said up left corner "sam will remember that" like how else would I have known that was her that talked on the radio, to be on that specific place and on that time of the day. And that Guy Carver 2.0 (something that kenny would never be), what was his deal? Except being a bad guy because bad being bad is good apparently. Being bad didn't saved him after i gave him to norma, jumped on me immediately and NORMA'S FACE after this omg.. she still got mad at me really?? Well sht even 11 year old kids got better self esteem and knew when to stop in that world. Oh and lets talk about destroying 1 boat nuked a whole city base on water oml..💀 Pete believing that all was needed was to talk, I refuse to believe he wasn't going to die because im sure we will still have the same ending where the city get nuked. All about that to say I didn't really liked it, it was like living season 2 again but because it was shorter with less character I didn't cared that much. Except I want to know, if that michonne is canon to the comics? I know for the tv show is more complicated to explain because its not the same media and for exemple rick had to die early on so the story about michonne and rick falling in love its not "canon" to the comics.
Overall my ranking in order:
Season 4
Season 1
Season 3
Michonne
400 days
Season 2
I have so much to say about season 2..oml the urge to just lay it all out but imma try to stop there
Are they ever going to go back make any other twd stories?