![Image 1 — [Mixed Trope] The character from the original had to be totally rewritten or removed altogether to make the adaptation work.](https://preview.redd.it/nt28c5nw6q2h1.jpg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fc63038c0e5eced9c451572d71b6e6d797865c62)
![Image 2 — [Mixed Trope] The character from the original had to be totally rewritten or removed altogether to make the adaptation work.](https://preview.redd.it/g7uut3nw6q2h1.jpg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bbd413c87a0f91bf3140206d4d5177f358478997)
[Mixed Trope] The character from the original had to be totally rewritten or removed altogether to make the adaptation work.
Black Noir — The Boys (comics/show)
In the original run of The Boys, Black Noir is the highly deadly, silent, masked enforcer for the Vought corporation, only to be revealed in the series’ conclusion to be an evil clone of Homelander and the secret villain of the entire series. In the live action adaptation, Noir was totally rewritten into two entirely different characters playing the “Noir” role. One is a brain-damaged old school Supe who copes with his trauma via Bucky Beaver drawings. The other is a narcoleptic theater kid who loves to remind people he can fly. The show runners thought Noir’s original role and villain story to be too extreme, and cut it entirely.
Tom Bombadil — Lord of the Rings
Probably the most cliche example of this trope. In Tolkein’s original trilogy, Tom Bombadil is an enigmatic primeval being residing in a forest near the Shire. He predates all magic, and is thus totally immune to the Ring and its corrupting effects, and is powerful enough to resist any who might try to take it. But the Fellowship is forced to continue their journey to Mordor because Tom is so laid-back and carefree that he fails to see the importance of destroying the Ring. Gandalf argues that, even if he did take the Ring, he would eventually lose it or forget about it, thus allowing it to fall into the wrong hands. Understandably, his entire character was totally removed from the film adaptation.