u/Crisgu

Fee Simple + Perpetual Tax vs. 70-Year State Leaseholds: How do these property models impact long-term urban development and infrastructure assembly?

Hello all!

I’ve been reflecting on how property rights directly dictate the lifespan and adaptability of our cities. In the West, we hold fee simple titles but face perpetual property taxation and zoning limits. In contrast, places like China utilize state-owned land with 70-year residential use-rights, allowing the state a sovereign reset button on urban layout when leases expire.

Essentially, both systems challenge the concept of absolute, allodial ownership: one functions via perpetual tax "rent," the other via direct state leasing.

I'd love to hear perspectives from planners, municipal employees, and international developers on the structural trade-offs here:

Land Assembly & Redevelopment: Does the fee simple model create insurmountable bottlenecks for major infrastructure and density upgrades due to holdouts, whereas leasehold systems streamline urban renewal?

Public Planning vs. Individual Liberty: How do these systems balance personal stability and wealth generation with a city's need to adapt to changing demographics and climate realities over a century?

Funding: What are the planning trade-offs between a system funded by recurring local property taxes versus one funded by state-level land allocation?

If you have worked or studied urban systems under both frameworks, how did the legal reality of "ownership" change the physical reality of the built environment?

Thanks.

reddit.com
u/Crisgu — 1 day ago

What are the fiscal and market efficiency trade-offs between fee simple ownership with perpetual property taxation versus state-owned, time-limited leaseholds (i.e., 70-year residential leases)?

I am looking for an economic comparison between two distinct land tenure and municipal funding models:

1 - The Western/U.S. Model: Fee simple title coupled with perpetual property taxation. Local governments rely on recurring property taxes to fund public services and infrastructure, using foreclosure as the ultimate enforcement mechanism for non-payment.

2 - The East Asian/Chinese Model: State ownership of land with time-limited residential land-use rights (typically 70 years). Local governments generate significant upfront revenue via land-use renewals or sales, rather than relying heavily on annual property taxes.

From a macroeconomic and public finance perspective, how do these two models alter long-term capital investment incentives for property maintenance and development as a lease nears its expiration?

Also, which system is more efficient at capturing unearned land value appreciation (land value capture) for public use?
And
How do these models impact housing affordability, market volatility, and the fiscal stability of local governments over multi-decade horizons?

Looking for insights grounded in public economics, urban economics, or relevant empirical studies.

reddit.com
u/Crisgu — 1 day ago
▲ 3 r/Albany

Looking for a Good Insurance Broker Around Albany/Capital Region

Hey everyone, hope you’re well!

I found out that my premiums are all about $100 or so higher as renewal time approaches. I personally find it absurd that others submit claims and our premiums also go up when we never used any insurance.

With that said, I’m looking for recommendations for a solid insurance broker in the Capital Region. Usually online brokerage companies sell your data and next thing you know you’re getting a ton of marketing spam so I try to avoid those.

I’m currently looking for someone who can help bundle and properly review:

Umbrella, Rental property coverage, Homeowner’s and auto insurance.

Mainly looking for someone responsive, knowledgeable, and honest, especially someone who actually looks for the best coverage price instead of just entering data and pushing policies 😅

Would love to hear who you’ve had good experiences with, and who to avoid.

Thanks in advance!

reddit.com
u/Crisgu — 7 days ago
▲ 3 r/Albany

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for recommendations on the best social platforms, forums, or online groups for staying connected with the Capital Region community (Albany and surrounding areas). I’m interested in local events, discussions, recommendations, buy/sell, getting to know people and the neighborhood. You know, general local engagement.
I’ve tried Nextdoor and the Facebook group “Welcome to Albany,” but found both to be quite hostile and not very welcoming.
Are there better alternatives that are more positive and active?
Thanks in advance for any suggestions!

reddit.com
u/Crisgu — 14 days ago