u/DeathStarVet

S - Best. Self Explanatory

A - Great. Self Explanatory

B - A Fun Romp. I'll gladly watch these whenever they're on, and I'll put them on. They're fun, and they're Star Wars.

C - Not good. Honestly, I don't think there are any that are just "not good".

D - Retroactively Bad due to The Rise of Skywalker. Before TRoS came out, I would absolutely watch these movies, and they would probably both be B-Tier otherwise.

F - The Rise of Skywalker. This movie was so bad that it is the only Star Wars movie that I've ever watched only once (and I watched TPM 11 times in the theater; I still have the ticket stubs). The movie killed internal consistency, undid Anakin's sacrifice, and pandered to bad faith criticism of TLJ. TRoS showed that, yes, TFA really had no plan for the movie/sequels, no plan for the mystery boxes, and was just a cynical cash grab copy of ANH. In doing so it retroactively ruined the whole trilogy for me.

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post