
Borenstein: Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee’s audacious power grab has tone of Trump
Borenstein is boggled by Mayor Lee's push for a strong mayor reform, seeing it as far too susceptible to corruption and political manipulation.
>But Oakland’s problem is not the lack of a supreme leader. It’s the lack of objective financial guidance from an independent professional administrator, and leaders willing to put the city’s long-term good ahead of their immediate political ambitions.
That first sentence is certainly correct. It's questionable if the second one is correct, at least when stated as "this is Oakland's problem." You can get objective financial guidance and ignore it, as Oakland "leaders" have for many years.
Personally I'd say the main problem(s) with Oakland government are a toxic culture, and the fact that Oakland itself is full of deep political conflicts and wildly varying views about what the direction of the city should be. I think we're assuming that changing the form of government is going to fix things that it's not able to fix.