For me, it’s CatNap, without a doubt. I’d say CatNap is somewhere in between a broken villain and pure evil. Sorry, CatNap fans, but this cat committed quite a lot of atrocities in the name of the Prototype, and he was fully aware of what he was doing.
Even I can’t think of a plausible answer for this scenario.
Let’s suppose that the Thin Man simply decided to kill Six instead of trapping her in the tower. Would he be right or wrong to do that?
I'm going to state two truths and I want you to tell me yours! So let's go:
No, it's not fair to blame Lily for Gracie's actions. And what's more, Lily could have become a good person if she hadn't been isolated and had been guided down the right path by some genuinely good experiment, like Doey (which unfortunately would be hard to happen canonically).
Doey would never beat the Prototype (unfortunately 😭). Like, you just have to play Chapter 4. It's literally explained right in the player's face that Doey wouldn't defeat the Prototype head-on.
Now tell me more hard truths to accept about this franchise!
I find it so strange that Dogday was never mentioned again in the other chapters, not by the characters, nor in documents or VHS tapes. Like, couldn't Mob have added a dialogue from Poppy, Doey, or even Giblet talking about Dogday? With them saying something like: "I miss Dogday, he was one of our greatest allies." Dogday was literally the leader of the Smiling Critters, and Hoppy managed to get more lore than him in chapter 4.
Anyway, I find this Dogday situation really strange. It seems like Mob did this on purpose to make Dogday their personal punching bag. Besides being tortured, having his body eaten from the inside, and being controlled, his existence was also completely ignored by the other characters. Like, I know the other characters think all the Smiling Critters were killed, but a character being dead didn't stop Giblet from talking about Mommy, Catnap, and Doey. One of our allies could have easily mentioned Dogday.
Glitch! You'd better be preparing a special image for our GOAT Caine!
Like, I've seen a lot of people taking this as an absolute truth because she showed fear of the Prototype before dying, but was it officially confirmed that she no longer works for him?
Let's suppose, for example, that CatNap went after Poppy because she started a rebellion against his God and attacked her. How screwed is CatNap?
I believe most of us agree with the theory that we'll be playing as the Critters in this game, and that made me think: 'If we're going to control mini experiments in this game, maybe it will reveal something about Gentle John and the experiments that escaped!'
Gentle John's plot came up in Chapter 5, and I don't think Mob would create this plot just to abandon it. Maybe they will explore Gentle John's plot in this new game, since we will most likely be controlling the Critters to escape from certain places in the factory and from larger experiments.
Now, one thing that could debunk my theory is the existence of the sentence 'you must earn your place in our future.' This sentence might indicate that the mini experiments we'll be controlling in this game are following the Prototype's orders, which contradicts what the toys led by Gentle John did. But at the same time, the fact that this is almost certainly involved with the Hour of Joy makes me think that Gentle John's plot might be explored in this game, since the toys led by Gentle John apparently escaped during the Hour of Joy.
For some reason, I'm also predicting that Giblet will be an important character in this game, and I think the theory that Giblet might be Gentle John could actually be true.
I think Caine and Ribbit had a relatively good relationship, since Ribbit seemed to genuinely enjoy Caine's adventures (at least in all of Jax's memories where they were in one or had just returned from an adventure).
As for Kaufmo, I have no idea, but the guy was pretty chill, so he was probably chill with Caine too.
Let's assume that episode 7 wasn't an adventure, Abel was actually a human trying to help the cast escape, and Jax pressed the blue button, thus making everyone escape the Circus. How do you think Caine would react to this and what would he do afterward? Man, all I can say is that he would definitely be extremely upset about it...
These four immediately came to my mind. If I were to make a ranking, I think the most accurate would be like this: Fourth place: Doey. Third place: Poppy. Second place: Giblet. First place: Chum.
Even though Doey protected the Safe Haven for years, was a good leader, and knew how to operate the Safe Haven generator, he didn't show many other feats of intelligence beyond those.
Doey seems to recognize that Poppy had better leadership skills than him, and she demonstrates a lot of knowledge about the factory and the experiments—after all, she is one of the oldest experiments. But Poppy is still quite naive.
Giblet shows that he knows how to use equipment that only a specialized employee would know how to, so much so that there are various pieces of equipment in his hideout, in addition to the fact that Giblet realized the Safe Haven wasn't so safe after all. Giblet also shows he is one of the most mature experiments of all.
Chum also showed he knows how to operate machinery, read and explained to Giblet that the documents the Player got talked about the Negation Compound, plus he acts as a double agent for Giblet, and the Prototype (at least as far as we know) doesn't seem to suspect that he is a double agent.
Like, it bothers me that the characters didn't even try to at least talk to Caine more and treat him like a person. Like, couldn't they ask Caine to take away Jax's keys? The guy was literally invading their privacy, and I know Caine was kind of silly and didn't pay much attention to things, but I think he actually would care about the key situation if the humans talked to him.
Would the Prototype's regeneration be powerful enough to save him from that?
Seriously, I think Quora is BY FAR the place with the most character wanking. Quora powerscalers will take any statement from any media, no matter how obscure the media is or how contradictory the statement is, and scale any character to the most absurd level possible. Seriously, there's literally a 100% serious post on Quora about how Albert Wesker would beat Homelander no-low diff, because apparently Albert Wesker scales to mountain level with relativistic speed.